In Yichuan County, Luoyang City, Henan Province, there is a group of teenagers who are very bold and love ghost fire motorcycles, and they drive motorcycles on the road at night and roar willfully. However, the police found out about the situation and adopted a special means of punishment. They asked the teenagers to write a letter of guarantee and set up a WeChat group called the "Tiger Squad." In addition, within the specified time, these teenagers also need to come to the police station to wash police cars, clean police quarters, and burn expired archives. This move has sparked dissatisfaction and controversy among parents.
The behavior of these teenagers has aroused people's thinking and concern about family education. Parents believe that these children have been spoiled and indulged in family and school education for a long time, and they are unable to control themselves, and the punishment of the police has played a certain educational effect. Some parents expressed support for the police's approach, believing that it was not a bad thing to make their children suffer a little, and that they could learn from it and help them realize their mistakes and correct them.
However, some parents have questioned the practice of the police. They believe that the police have overstepped their authority by treating the children as "long-term workers" to clean up the police environment without parental consent, and that the police themselves should be in the role of protecting and educating minors, rather than using them for labor. Whether this practice is reasonable and whether it complies with laws and regulations has aroused the attention of ** and extensive discussion.
Many people support the practice of civilian police as a positive form of family education. They believe that today's children lack self-discipline and have poor cognitive ability of risks and consequences, and they need to guide them to establish correct values and codes of conduct through some compulsory educational means. They believe that although the punishment of the police is somewhat difficult, it is very necessary to educate the children.
Some proponents argue that children are not adequately disciplined in their home and school settings, which leads to their wayward behavior. The punishment of the police provides an opportunity for these children to go through some difficult consequences so that they can learn from them. It is a real-life way to teach children to be hardworking and respectful.
On the other hand, the practice of the civilian police has also been questioned. They felt that the civilian police had overstepped their authority in the process of punishing juveniles and had used an excessively harsh approach. They believe that although the children's violations were serious, they were only traffic violations and did not cause direct harm to others. Therefore, the use of compulsory education by the civilian police is a bit excessive.
Some opponents argue that the police should not treat the juveniles as "long-term workers" to clean up the police environment. They believe that this does not serve the purpose of education, and only makes children feel disgusted and resistant, without really realizing their mistakes. They advocate for more rational and appropriate education, such as involving them in community volunteering activities or receiving relevant traffic safety education courses.
As a parent, I think that the approach of the civilian police is to some extent positive. Children need to be guided and educated by their families, schools and society as they grow up, and this is exactly what the civilian police provide. They use a direct and powerful way to let the children experience first-hand the consequences of non-compliance, and through labor and cleaning, they make them aware of the negative impact of their actions on others and society.
However, I also agree with the naysayers. When dealing with juvenile issues, the people's police need to adopt appropriate ways and methods in accordance with laws and regulations. If the punishment of the police is too severe, it may cause dissatisfaction and doubts from parents, and may even violate the principle of protection of minors. Therefore, the civilian police need to weigh the pros and cons in dealing with such issues and ensure that the ways and means of education are reasonable and appropriate.
Finally, I think that the educational responsibility of parents is very important. They should work with the school and society to take responsibility for the education of children. Only in this way can children establish correct values, develop positive Xi of behavior, and be aware of the impact of their actions on others and society. The role of the police is to provide guidance and educational support, and to assist parents and society in educating their children.