I am a veteran lawyer who has been practicing for 20 years, mainly engaged in civil and commercial cases in marriage and family in recent years, and often undertook legal aid for death penalty cases in the early years, and often was sentenced to death in the first instance.
I have been following and tracking the Zhu Ling incident for a long time, I have long read Sun Wei's statement in Tianya, and the reason why I have been silent is that I think the case is still being solved, I don't want to provide Sun Wei with too much legal knowledge for her to counter-investigate, today I heard that Zhu Ling's father has made it clear that the case has been closed in an interview, and I, as a lawyer, are here to make some analysis of Sun Wei's statement, and talk about my own views for your reference:
There are a lot of questions in Sun Wei's statement. I will only select a few important and major issues to discuss, and there are many others, which I will analyze further when the time comes.
As we all know, there is a fixed way of thinking from the perspective of one's own position, a person who has committed a crime and committed poisoning acts, and a person who has not been poisoned, the angle and way of thinking are different, people's thinking can be very rigorous and free of loopholes after self-training, but the thinking pattern cannot change the angle because of one's own position.
Sun Wei's statement stated that such a case of poisoning that had been clearly filed, she was arrested (or may have been detained, and it was rumored on the Internet that she was expelled from Tsinghua University because of this), and the suspected crimes must be related to the crime of poisoning (such as the crime of disseminating dangerous goods, which involve public safety), and she signed the documents that must be signed for these compulsory measures (8-hour interrogation) carried out against her, and she must have seen the suspected crimes related to poisoning very clearly, but she wrote it as a poisoning case in the statement, and she deliberately avoided poisoning, which is why？Why is she so afraid to mention the word poisoning, and only talks about poisoning cases throughout the article, and in her letters with friends, she has repeatedly asked for information on primary poisoning and non-secondary poisoning, so as to prove that it was the hospital's delay and misdiagnosis that caused Zhu Ling's disability, and why can't she face the fact that Zhu Ling was poisoned so far?
Sun Wei gave her ** when he looked at the seriously ill Zhu Ling, which read: "Zhu Ling, I wish you a speedy **!."
I am a lawyer, and I have long analyzed the testimony of witnesses and the confessions and statements of the defendants, and in my practice, I have found that many defendants who have been sentenced to death in the first instance can spend an entire morning talking to you about the causes and consequences of this matter, and talk about the causes and consequences of this matter in great detail, but he just avoids talking about the situation at the scene of the murder, and once I get to the core and key issues, they get stuck. Sun Wei can talk about her grandfather in detail, talk about this and that, before and after, left and right, but she just doesn't talk about any details related to Zhu Ling's poisoning!A reporter from Phoenix Satellite TV also mentioned it in an interview, saying that she could tell the weather in detail on a certain day, but when it came to key issues, she answered the question and was vague. In the end, even the on-site reporters who sympathized with her highly suspected that she was **, and the interview was interrupted, and she walked away.
There are many loopholes in Sun Wei's statement, and I will only mention one or two here. Among them, she said that Zhu Ling's decoction was not in the dormitory after returning to school, she clearly remembered that Zhu Ling wanted to decoction and was not in the dormitory, which shows that she is extremely concerned about her life trajectory, and her purpose in talking about this detail is intended to imply to netizens that she Zhu Ling may not have been poisoned in the dormitory, and it is entirely possible that she was elsewhere. This is actually a unique mindset that only poisoners have, and only people who have poisoned in the dormitory will be so eager to divert their attention, because she wants to transfer the scene of poisoning outside the dormitory that has nothing to do with her, and people who have not been poisoned will first pay attention to who poisoned them, not poisoned in ** (because he has not been poisoned, he is not poisoned in ** Poisoning is naturally no concept), and then there is the suspicion that all other people may be poisoned, including their own roommates, everyone is a suspect in the eyes of those who have not been poisoned and have been wronged, but Sun Wei has never suspected any of her roommates, but in her statement, she focused on implying that she was not in the dormitory at the crime scene. This is a very important mindset that only poisoners have.
When I was in college, there were many thefts in the dormitory opposite, I lost my food today, I lost my meal ticket and money tomorrow, and I lost my camera the day after tomorrowIt stands to reason that Sun Wei is a suspect, and the other roommates are also suspects as a matter of course, why don't these suspects suspect each other, when the poisoning case occurs?There is no prevarication because they must have some kind of common interests, which leads to their unity to this day, this unity is definitely not a good character worthy of belief, there is no way to pack a ticket for character, not that you are excellent in character and learning, you will not break the law and commit crimes, there is no inevitable logical relationship between the two. So when the police interrogated the roommate, and the roommate was anxious to bleach Sun Wei's character, the police couldn't make a confession record. Sun Wei even questioned this, why don't the police record my good character?Why don't you use the presumption of innocence under the criminal law?I think there's only one reason why they're still in a group, and they're so united and never suspicious of each other, and that's because they know exactly who the poisoners are, and that's why they're so relieved to twist together.
Sun Wei's entire statement is actually a defense of her innocence, and it is this defense of innocence that exposes her specific thinking pattern of the poisoner. We all know that what a really wronged person is most anxious to do is to clear up the wrongs, among the uncles and nephews who have been wronged in Zhejiang, whether it is an uncle who has not admitted his guilt or a nephew who has confessed his guilt, what they are most concerned about is who is **. Uncle is very concerned about all the details of the ** case and the people he highly suspects, because he knows that only by catching the real ** can he return his innocence, but Sun Wei's statement does not see this, from 1995 to the present for almost 20 years, she does not care who ** is, and even in all the texts she has been made public, there has never been a suspicion of anyone, she has been trying to find a way to study how to poison once and not twice ( She knows very well that it is possible to be poisoned once, and it is impossible to be poisoned but artificially poisoned twice), she is full of ways to make her suspected poisoning get away with it, she never wanted to find the real poisoning**, she even went to the hospital to misdiagnose the research, who is the real **?Why didn't she care in the first place?
For a person who has not been poisoned and wronged, random suspicion is his lifeline, and the wronged person does not hesitate to doubt anyone who can be doubted, but Sun Wei's group has never shown any specific thinking that only those who have been wronged have when they are scolded on the Internet and jumped over the wall in a hurry, that is, they accused Pei Zhicheng to vent their anger. She pointed the contradiction at Bei, not a real suspicion, but the practice of complicating things and confusing the line of sight, and this pattern of behavior is a mode of revenge in which the poisoner is exposed. In addition, she doesn't have any anger towards **, Angry emotions, not to mention her good quality, high legal awareness, no evidence and no suspicion, the dog is anxious to jump over the wall, people are wronged as murderers, the instinct is to doubt everything, instead of busy clearing themselves, only poisoned people will have the consciousness of defending themselves, there is a difference between defense and clearing the wrongs, the focus of the defense is that I do not constitute a crime, from the outside of the legal provisions and evidence (rather than from the facts themselves) to find the reason for their own guilt, and to clear the injustice is to try to find and find the truth, to find the truth, to find the real ** Also clear their innocence.
When talking about the motive, Sun Wei has a very strong sense of defense, that is, he was not at the scene, he had no motive for committing the crime, and he didn't know everything related to the case, even the toxicity of thallium. This is a typical sense of defense, and her focus is on fear that she will say something wrong, to stay away from the truth, to be afraid of the truth, to confuse the truth. And the people who really didn't poison the people had a thinking pattern: who is the ** in the end. If I were involved, I would have been framed, and she would be interested in the evidence that framed her, and would try her best to find it to study the flaws. She never had this kind of awareness, her consciousness was that there was no evidence, and it was repeatedly emphasized that there was no evidence.
Sun Wei especially emphasized the evidence when defending herself, she said that Zhu Ling's family admitted that there was no evidence, and said that she was **, and she was very puzzled by this. She clings to the fact that there is no evidence, why?The most important concern of the person who poisoned is whether there is evidence to be caught by others, and if there is no evidence to be caught, he is not guilty. Instead of thinking like ordinary people, I really didn't do it, I don't care if you have evidence, what evidence you have, I just haven't done it, the fact is that it's not me, what I care about is the facts. Suspecting others without evidence is the typical thinking of people who have not been poisoned, and people who have been poisoned will think that there is evidence to prove, and without evidence it cannot be proven, and the requirements for evidence are very high.
Sun Wei mentioned once in an email to his classmates, sisters, it's time for me to go to the execution ground (to the effect) She is not talking about the battlefield, but the execution ground, I feel special about the word execution ground, ordinary people don't know how to use this word, a person who has never committed a crime, may imagine that he dies, but will never imagine himself going to the execution ground, the word execution field was blurted out by her, it can be seen that the scene of the execution ground, in Sun Wei's mind, I don't know how many times?Why did you think of going to the execution ground yourself?Hehe.
I am a lawyer, I have basic legal knowledge, I understand the basic principles of law, so I know that in our lifetime, we may not see Sun Wei go to the execution ground, and the execution ground can only occasionally appear in Sun Wei's mind, or when she sweats in her midnight dream, she thinks about what nightmare she had.
We all know that the police must collect evidence, and that she cannot be arrested without evidence, that the procuratorate cannot prosecute her without evidence, that the court cannot convict her without evidence, and that she is indeed legally innocent. She is free to live in this world until the end of her life. She is likely to live so hatefully and healthily under our noses for the rest of her life, and she will even live longer than Zhu Ling.
The law cannot convict her, but the public can analyze whether she is guilty or not, can reason, can call her a suspect, and the only suspect.
The public can analyze, doubt, and verify, and this process of analysis and verification can follow her for a lifetime, and I hope that this doubt will always exist, and a hundred years later, our descendants will still question her here!Generations.
The first time I saw the report of this case, I remember sitting alone in front of the computer and crying like a child, and the second time I saw the case, I cried again. I didn't even know why I was crying so badly and embarrassed.
I have undertaken many legal aid death penalty cases, one case was remanded for retrial by the High Court, and one case was included in the selected cases of the Zhejiang Provincial High Court, I defended many death row prisoners sincerely and diligently, I often do not believe that the clients I handle are guilty, I always think they are innocent, and I often have a professional habit of pity for all the defendants suspected of crimes in the world, but this time, I undoubtedly believe that Sun Wei is guilty, she is the poisoner, she is **!
Copyright Notice: This article**network, the author is unknown, only for exchange and learning, the copyright belongs to the original author, if **marked wrong or infringes on your rights and interests, please inform, we will deal with it immediately.