I am a Chinese teacher, and when I teach the text "The Cowherd and the Weaver Girl", I use heuristic teaching, which allows students to familiarize themselves with the pre-Xi texts before class, and then the students ask questions and the teacher answers them.
I think this kind of classroom design is very good, which not only stimulates students' enthusiasm for reading, but also allows children to learn to think.
Who knows, as soon as class started, the students raised their hands one after another and raised a series of questions like a barrage, which made me confused for a while.
Teacher, the Cowherd is a thief, right?He steals other people's clothes, is this illegal?”
Teacher, the cowherd is lustful and a hooligan, and he ** fairy baths. This is going to be a lawsuit. ”
Teacher, I think the Cowherd wants to be cultured or uneducated, to have money or not, to have good looks and no good looks, why does the Weaver Girl fall in love with him, is it stupid?You were deceived, right?”
Teacher, my mother said that this text is like a small yellow text, and she wants to write a letter suggesting that the Ministry of Education delete it from the Chinese textbook, and she also suggests that the teacher should not talk about it, the more she talks about it, the uglier it becomes!”
For a while, the classmates talked a lot and raised a lot of questions, which really made me not expect that today's children are too powerful.
The students raised questions, and it was time for me, the teacher, to answer them, how should this lesson be conducted?
I had to bite the bullet and do my best to answer these questions to the students.
I said that this text is a Chinese textbook compiled by the Ministry of Education, and the Cowherd is a bitter child, his parents died, he was bullied by his brother and sister-in-law, he didn't get a share of the family property, and he only depended on an old cow for his life.
Until one day, the old cow suddenly spoke: "Tomorrow at dusk, some fairies will bathe in the lake......Pick up the pink garment and run into the woods to wait, for the fairy you want to dress for is your wife. ”
The next day, the Cowherd happily went.
Later, the Cowherd really took away the Weaver Girl's clothes, and the Weaver Girl had no way to fly to the Heavenly Palace, she saw that the Cowherd was kind and real, and the two of them became husband and wife and lived a happy life.
Some classmates questioned that it was illegal for the Cowherd to steal clothes, and it should be affirmed that this kind of critical thinking is very good and should have independent thinking.
If the Cowherd were living today, the Cowherd's actions would not only be suspected of theft, but also of illegal detention.
According to article 238 of the Criminal Law, anyone who illegally detains another person or illegally deprives another person of his personal liberty by other means shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not more than three years, short-term detention, controlled release or deprivation of political rights.
The Cowherd's practice is to "illegally deprive others of their personal liberty by other means", which is the same as the act of "illegally detaining others", which is a criminal act.
Some classmates questioned that the Cowherd peeked at people taking a bath, ** people's privacy is also illegal, it should be seen this way, if it is today, this kind of behavior properly violates the privacy of others, it is a hooligan.
Some classmates said that the Cowherd has no culture and no good looks, and the Weaver Girl has been deceived. Some parents said that the text "The Cowherd and the Weaver Girl" is a small yellow text, and it is recommended to take it off the shelves.
If you want me to say, these doubts are very good, the ancients said that "it is better to believe in the book, than to have no book", reading is to have your own thinking, dare to question, ask questions, solve problems, in order to learn true knowledge.
Next, the teacher will share my own views and discuss with my classmates.
First, "The Cowherd and the Weaver Girl" is a folk tale that has been passed down from generation to generation, word of mouth, and enduring, expressing people's yearning and pursuit of a better life.
Second, since it is a folk tale, it must be judged in the long river of history, and cannot be interpreted by the eyes of modern people and the law.
For example, when we watch a science and education movie, we see a prehistoric human holding a stone and cutting flesh there, you won't laugh at him for his strong limbs and simple mind, right?On the contrary, you will admire in your heart that Homo sapiens is really powerful and knows how to make tools.
Because of the different historical stages and different values, we cannot look at the ancients through the eyes of today.
Third, the Cowherd and the Weaver Girl are mythical stories and are the product of the wisdom of the ancients. First of all, the cow spoke, which is unconventional, so the whole story cannot be understood with convention.
Secondly, the Cowherd took away the Weaver Girl's clothes, and there is no ** bathing plot in the story, so people can't be lustful today.
The Cowherd took away the Weaver Girl's clothes so that the Weaver Girl could come to him, not to keep the Weaver Girl's clothes for himself, so this is not the same as the concept of stealing.
Fourth, some parents suggested that this text be taken off the shelves, and the editors, publishing houses, the Ministry of Education, and the relevant responsible persons of the school should be held responsible, which is a bit extreme, and we learn Xi story of "The Cowherd and the Weaver Girl" is to learn Xi the kindness and diligence of the Cowherd and the Weaver Girl, the courage to pursue a better life and the extraordinary imagination of the ancients. We learn Xi what is beautiful and what is bad.
We must look at this story from the perspective of the ancients, and then analyze this story from the perspective of today's people, analyze the characteristics of the character of the Cowherd, and get more inspiration from it. Instead of picking the thorns of the ancients, no matter how good the story is, there are flaws, and you must understand the meaning of the idiom "flaws do not hide Yu".
After class, the students felt that the class was good, the students fully expressed their opinions, the teacher summarized them, and the students learned a lot of knowledge.
What do you think about this?Thank you for your support!