A platform asked: When Liu Bei wanted to go east, why didn't Zhuge Liang say a word to advise?
I answer:
Today, I answer this question from a relatively unique perspective.
First of all, the title said, "During the Eastern Crusade, why didn't Zhuge Liang say a word to advise." ”
This description is a bit wrong, because Zhuge Liang should have some advice, but the advice was ineffective, and the historical description of this advice was not recorded, probably because the process of Zhuge Liang's advice was too chatty, or relatively private.
However, Zhuge Liang's attitude towards Liu Bei's Eastern Expedition was still recorded and recorded in the Fa Zheng Biography.
The ancestor is the honorific title, and will go east to conquer Sun Quan to restore the shame of Guan Yu, and the ministers will admonish many times, but they will not obey. In the second year of Zhang Wu, the army was defeated and the White Emperor was returned. Liang sighed and said: "If the law is filial piety, then it can control the lord's order not to go east;."and when they return to the east, they will not fall into danger. Although only one sentence of Zhuge Liang's exclamation is recorded in the whole paragraph, Zhuge Liang did not approve of the Eastern Crusade and advised him, and I have based this historical inference on the record of "Three Kingdoms".
After talking about this inference, let's talk about the next question, why Zhuge Liang persuaded him, but he couldn't persuade him to death. It is also commonly known as the death admonition.
After all, as the second most powerful person in the team, Zhuge Liang's record of disapproval of the Eastern Crusade has been recorded in history, and the weak and weak persuasion may not have been recorded in the history books, only recording Zhuge Liang's public emotion before the minister of Shu Han.
So much so that many people think that Zhuge Liang, as the only important minister of Shu Han, why didn't he advise him to the death?
At this time, we need to retreat from God and return to people, that is, to withdraw the sacred aura on Zhuge Liang and treat him as a political figure.
The so-called, politicians, there must be political forces, Zhuge Liang is no exception, there is no faction in the party, and there are all kinds of strangeness. Zhuge Liang, as the second-in-command of Shu Han, is strange if there is no faction.
Zhuge Liang's faction is the Jingzhou faction, which runs through all the colors of Zhuge Liang's own body, and Zhuge Liang's favorite people are also the Jingzhou faction, Ma Yan, Jingzhou people, Jiang Wan, Jingzhou people.
This answer is the reason why Zhuge Liang didn't persuade Liu Bei to the death, because the willingness to fight in the Battle of Yiling was the strongest Jingzhou faction in Liu Bei's group, and Liu Bei relied on Jingzhou to send it, and politicians could not disobey the simple will of the basic market, otherwise they would lose the support of the political base.
applied to Zhuge Liang, that is, Zhuge Liang could communicate with Liu Bei when he could chat privately, and suggested that he should not fight Jingzhou. However, I can't openly express my stance that I am against Jingzhou.
Zhuge Liang dared to openly oppose the Eastern Crusade, which was against the will of the Jingzhou faction.
The people of Jingzhou will also strongly oppose the Eastern Crusade because of Zhuge Liang. Therefore, there is a diaphragm for Zhuge Liang (people in Jingzhou will think so, it turns out that you Zhuge Liang is not the boss of our faction).
Therefore, based on such inferences, we can understand why Zhuge Liang could not strongly oppose the Eastern Crusade from the public level.
100 help plan