If you're in trouble, as the only son in the family, have you considered what your parents would do?
The firefighter who had just walked out of the rescue scene was stunned when he faced the reporter's question, and then his eyes were full of tears.
It was difficult to balance loyalty and filial piety, and the firefighters fell silent. This has been the case since ancient times.
The reporter seemed to be unconcerned about the awkward atmosphere and continued to ask for "answers".
I can't answer that question.
Eventually, at the end of the interview, the firefighter choked up and gave an answer.
In 2015, a serious safety accident occurred in Tianjin's Binhai New Area, resulting in the tragic death of nearly 100 firefighters who came to participate in the rescue.
After hearing the news, countless people felt sad and indignant at the reporter's unhumane questioning.
She was criticized by everyone, and all kinds of vicious remarks quickly spread on her social accounts, and even the topic of "get out of the hosting world" quickly appeared on the hot search list.
This reporter is the famous CCTV host - Dong Qian.
Dong Qian has always been highly praised and criticized by the outside world. Her eloquence has been praised for her ability to tell the truth when interviewing, which shows her most basic professionalism as a journalist.
Some people think that the way she interviews lacks warmth, lacks the most basic respect when talking to others, and appears aggressive, caustic, and overly aloof.
What does she really look like?
The controversy caused by Dong Qian can be traced back to her remarks about Chinese women's volleyball coach Lang Ping in an interview in 2013.
When you were the head coach of the U.S. team at the time, would you feel entangled in your heart when facing the Chinese team?
Those who are familiar with Lang Ping know that as an athlete, she won countless honors for her country during her time in the women's volleyball team. Even after moving to the United States as a coach, she still cherishes her homeland.
As soon as he heard that the Chinese women's volleyball team was in trouble, he immediately returned to China quickly and did his best to help the women's volleyball team get out of the predicament.
Perhaps the only regret in Lang's coaching career is that she led the U.S. team to defeat China at the 2008 Olympics. As a result, interviewers usually try to avoid touching on this awkward topic.
Dong Qian unabashedly asked Lang Ping a straightforward question, which completely touched her sensitive nerves.
However, at that time, people mainly criticized Dong Qian for her business level and professionalism, and there was not much controversy about her personal qualities.
The real reason why she ended up getting involved in the ** maelstrom was the two interviews she conducted with two firefighters.
The 2015 Tianjin** incident was mentioned for the first time, while the second was a forest fire in Liangshan, Sichuan, in 2019.
It was supposed to bring life to people in early spring, but a fire in Liangshan made people feel like they were in a cold winter, and 27 firefighting heroes closed their eyes forever, and the youngest firefighter was only 23 years old......
Dong Qian, as a reporter, also rushed to the forefront to carry out interview and reporting work.
What is your relationship with that comrade-in-arms?
In the face of Dong Qian's inquiry, the expression of the fire fighter showed some confusion.
As a survivor, he has just survived a tragic disaster, not only losing his comrades-in-arms who accompany him day and night, but also leaving a deep psychological shadow. He really didn't know what else to react to besides tears.
Would you like to help him?
Dong Qian's problems continued, but the psychological condition of the firefighters had begun to show pressure.
I had a rescue in mind, but it was too late. If I go back and pull him, I'm afraid I'll be trapped inside.
There is a kind of pain called having more than enough heart, and there is a kind of sadness called silence.
Do you blame yourself?
Dong Qian's way of asking questions made the firefighters feel very anxious, and also caused dissatisfaction among many netizens.
Everyone was in a state of flux, and people condemned Dong Qian's ruthlessness.
Netizens are looking forward to the comfort of the hero, not the unsympathetic mechanical indifference, like tearing open the wounds of others and sprinkling salt.
This is not an interview, but a harsh questioning!
Dong Qian got out of the hosting world" This topic quickly detonated on the whole network, and she seemed to have become the target of public criticism overnight.
Some people even dug up Dong Qian's ugly things in the past, and then attacked her one after another.
In an interview, Dong Qian was confronted with a driver who had the courage to stand up.
The driver encountered a robbery incident, and resolutely decided to bravely pursue the culprit regardless of his personal safety, and finally succeeded in knocking him down and successfully arresting him.
Netizens did not hesitate to applaud and praise this situation, but during the interview, Dong Qian maintained a blank face throughout the whole process and expressed a negative attitude towards righteousness and bravery.
Have you ever considered that robbers get hurt?What are your thoughts on this?
As soon as this remark came out, it immediately caused an uproar on the Internet.
Instead, he worried about the robber, did good deeds but was not praised, and did not mention the complicated feelings of the driver when he was interviewed, which made netizens express that they could not understand and find it even more difficult to accept.
Dong Qian's social mailbox has been flooded into a new wave again, with some demanding a public apology from her, while others calling on her to quit the hosting world.
In addition, some people revealed that Dong Qian showed "ruthlessness" in Wenchuan ** in 2008.
At that time, the whole country was paying close attention to every move there, and major ** sent reporters one after another, hoping to get first-hand reports. Dong Qian was one of the first journalists to contact the disaster area.
After Dong Qian arrived at the scene, she saw the devastated city, and she was touched by the cries that rang in her ears from time to time.
She walked up to a child who had just escaped and asked in a low voice, "How are you feeling?"Does it hurt to be pressed underneath?Have you ever felt hopeless?"She's got her goals set.
There was no official statement this time, but her ordinary words sounded harsh to people.
Did she really ever think about other people's emotions?
Many people became suspicious, but at the time everyone was focused on disaster relief, and the matter was put on hold.
When interviewing Zheng Yumin, Dong Qian sat and talked and teased him, while Zheng Yumin responded with the height of his heel, alluding to the injustice of both sides.
Subsequently, Dong Qian compared private enterprises to arms and asked Zheng Yumin for his opinion on this, but he still refuted her in watertight terms.
Dong Qian asked Zheng Yumin a series of pointed questions, involving Warren Buffett's dinner, Gates's visit, and the overall image of the rich second generation.
However, the latter calmly resolved all the challenges one by one, and even gradually forced the other party into a situation of speechlessness.
Netizens have expressed that they are very relieved to see this scene, and regard this war of words as a classic.
She was labelled "cold-blooded and ruthless", and when she was criticized for her interviews, people were happy to see her frustrated;When someone condemned her, netizens joined in the condemnation.
Dong Qian is known as "getting out of the hosting world", but is she really as unbearable as netizens are?
Bai Yansong once said: "A good journalist is not like a magpie that makes people happy every day, but like a woodpecker who is good at spotting subtleties, and the real facts are hidden in the details." ”
She has more than 20 years of experience in the professional field and has never made a major mistake. She is adept at finding the crux of the problem quickly and strives to provide the most truthful coverage for the public to get more direct information.
During the epidemic, Dong Qian was fortunate to interview Academician Zhang Boli, who was known as the "anti-epidemic hero".
You came on January 27th, and what assignments did you receive at that time?
Academician Zhang's softness in his heart was touched, and he became excited when answering a seemingly ordinary question, stating the bitterness and hardship he experienced when fighting the epidemic in Wuhan.
When he was emotionally excited, he couldn't help but take off his glasses and choked up to wipe the tears from his eyes.
No one has ever asked me such a question, and it immediately touched my emotions, and you are so perceptive.
What attracts more readers is a lively and rich report, but this also means that it may stay at the level of "storytelling" and be suspected of being false.
Professionals have shared their insights into journalists' interview techniques, pointing out that if the interview is conducted mechanically according to the manuscript provided, the answer is often just a "carefully packaged" story.
Interviewees tend to be wary and nervous when confronted with reporters, and often instinctively choose to say something that meets public expectations for self-defense, rather than easily revealing their true thoughts.
Dong Qian's sharp interviews can shorten people's reaction time and more easily disrupt the rhythm of the other party, thus inadvertently prompting them to tell the truth.
Obviously, this strategy works well for interviewing celebrities, but it doesn't work well for firefighters.
Dong Qian is not cold and ruthless, nor is she lacking in empathy.
The scene of Dong Qian choking up and crying when broadcasting Wenchuan ** is a heart-wrenching memory of the disaster in 2008, but everyone only learned about her inappropriate soul three questions.
Many people have overlooked Dong Qian's courage, she faced the aftershocks without fear, and dared to go to the front line to report the most real disaster situation and provide information to the public.
How many people are **?What is the number of people rescued?Have the supplies been delivered?At what stage has the troops penetrated to?
Dong Qian's colleagues revealed that her eyes were always red and swollen during that time, and she cried many times at the work site, but once she started working, she was able to quickly adjust her state, show her strongest and calm side, and impress the public.
Dong Qian published a book called "Understanding" in 2017.
In the book, she compiles some of her own experiences and interviews, and shows readers the rapid changes in the hearts of interviewees through a large number of in-depth interview cases.
Although I am approaching step by step, I can't bear it in my heart.
Dong Qian has always been aware of the criticism and scolding of the outside world, and she has tried to understand and comfort those who are in pain.
But once you go back to your roots, you will find that the real news story is about telling things in the most concise language possible, with the fewest words.
Soon after Bai Yansong entered the industry, he had become a big man in the hosting industry at that time, and many juniors, including Dong Qian, regarded him as a role model and a target for Xi.
The choreographer gave the example of Bai Yansong: interviewing Mr. Bai, he only needs 30 minutes to get the information he wants, while you need two hours. Does anyone want to waste time like this?
What do you think is the purpose of the interview?”
Dong Qian's lingering questions also prompted her to find a unique style.
Bring the interviewee back to the scene at that time, without adding unnecessary embellishments, just the most resolute paraphrase. A sparkle that combines individuality and humanity.
Dong Qian has always believed that the host should consider the impact of the incident on society and others during the interview.
Repeated cold questioning is undoubtedly a continuous impact on the heart.
Imagine if journalists were to disguise their calm with rhetoric, who would have remembered the importance of preventing forest fires
The story has been given the form of a story, but the story is far from reality.
Dong Qian seems to ignore the heroism of the driver, and this indifference is not uncommon, after all, there are many incidents where people have been injured and eventually sentenced for saving others.
In 2017, Dong Qian interviewed the mother of a heart organ donor.
To show gratitude, the individual who received the donation recorded the sound of the heart beating, hoping that the deceased child would continue to be with the mother in this way.
Are you looking forward to hearing your daughter's heartbeat again?
Dong Qian hesitated for a long time, but finally decided to take out the recording.
After a moment of silence, the mother shook her head and said, "Although I want to, I don't dare." ”
Why do you mention many times that you dream of seeing your daughter, but you are afraid to listen to the sound of your heart beating at your hand?
I was awakened by the sound of my daughter's heart beating, which made me realize that she would never come back......
Dong Qian realized that she might have touched the sore spot of others again, and suddenly burst into tears. She apologized softly to her mother, but her mother comforted her in turn.
She gave up the interview for the first time because she faced the skinny and dying Lin Ru in "Swapping Life for Mother".
In "Orphan Yang Liujin", Dong Qian bravely issued an accountability to the local authorities, facing those children who survived by eating grass in the deep mountains.
Dong Qian is not as cold-blooded and ruthless as most people think, and she has always been very empathetic.
In 2020, when the epidemic broke out in Wuhan, Dong Qianyi did not hesitate to go to the place where the epidemic was most serious.
Through more than 40 reports on the disaster, Dong Qian has let people see the most real situation in Wuhan under the epidemic, and also witnessed the sincere goodwill between many people.
Xia Bin, a truck driver, shoots funny** to bring joy to others, but suffers from illness alone;Cai Liping is a first-class leader, she endured the pain of losing her husband and set an example for her colleagues;Gan Ruyi is a brave girl who insists on returning to her post even if she is thousands of miles away.
In a face-to-face interview, more than 100 people shared countless touching and true stories.
Dong Qian's actions have made more people realize the greatness of ordinary people, and it has also shown the world why Chinese can stand up again and again in the face of disasters.
However, what many people don't know is that the reason why Dong Qian was able to appear on the front line of the epidemic was because she submitted 6 consecutive applications to apply to her superiors.
Dong Qian's son hugged her tightly before she left, crying and begging his mother not to leave. However, out of the professional ethics of a journalist, Dong Qian finally decided to leave for Wuhan.
She has been engaged in this industry for more than 20 years, and has always been known for her truth-seeking and pragmatic "CCTV celebrity", she is not lacking in warmth, but out of the choice of the truth, she adopts a ruthless style of revealing scars.
Dong Qian's choice of this style is likely related to her experience when she entered the industry, and her upbringing had an extremely profound impact on her.
Those who graduated from Peking University have some self-confidence in their hearts, and Dong Qian is no exception, she is a typical representative of "newborn calves are not afraid of tigers".
However, a split second can turn self-confidence into low self-esteem.
Dong Qian majored in history during college, and it was already difficult to find employment across industries, not to mention that she entered the talent-rich "Focus Interview".
Dong Qian was almost in a state of inferiority in her first job.
It seems that the people around her are always busy, busy with their own affairs every day, and she sits at her desk like a log with nothing to do.
Dong Qian has a tenacious character, so she is not willing to give up easily. In her spare time, she humbly consulted others to supplement her professional knowledge, and gradually found some breakthroughs.
A year later, Dong Qian was transferred from her job as an editor to a reporter for Son of the East, a transition from behind the scenes to in front of the scenes, which brought her new challenges.
Dong Qian has always been very serious about her efforts, recording questions and asking questions afterwards during every visit, and sorting out notes when she returns home.
Her efforts finally paid off for an interview, but the results were not as expected.
Despite being well prepared, the interview with the experts was still cramped and uneasy, and the entire interview lacked focus and failed to dig deep into some key information.
Dong Qian has struggled with mistakes for the past few years, and her ears are filled with accusations from colleagues and criticism from superiors.
Even the producers who chose her to join the group expressed some dissatisfaction.
I've always been very accurate in my selection of moderators, but your boss and colleagues are reporting that you're not doing well. I had to start wondering if I was looking at the wrong person and needed to be more vigilant not to let you be my first wrong choice.
After that conversation, Dong Qian's original retreat in her heart became firm again.
Dong Qian later got a chance to go to the United States to study Xi.
There, she rediscovered the importance of her work as a journalist and had a clearer understanding of the question of what the purpose of the interview was.
Dong Qian believes that in order to conduct a successful interview, you must first not lose to the other party in momentum, so you must fully prepare relevant materials.
The key to interviewing is to make sure it's "accurate".
CCTV and other mainstream ** interviews cover senior experts and celebrities from all walks of life, and if the questions are not accurate, it will give the other party the impression that you lack professional knowledge, which will affect the possibility of in-depth dialogue with the other party.
Their conversation was difficult to continue, and the answers they received were probably perfunctory.
Dong Qian's interview style is becoming more and more sharp and intuitive, she adheres to the standard of objectivity and truth, and can easily go deep into the essence of things, so the outside world has mixed doubts about her.
Dong Qian is still at the forefront of journalism, and despite many rumors and doubts around her, she still chooses to solve the problem straightforwardly.
Her job is to explore journalism, and she pursues objectivity and truth, even if she is criticized as cold-blooded, she believes that she will not change her sharp interview style.
Instead, he will choose to continue to use his eyes and mind to travel to every corner with more people and experience more of life.
Dong Qian has experienced the process from "CCTV celebrity" to "getting out of the hosting world".
I hope that Dong Qian will have all the best in the coming days, because as time goes by, people's prejudice against others will gradually decrease.