Cao Pi will die in shame, the purpose of which is that he will not only care about the hearts of the people, but also make the traitor pay the price. But compared to his father, Cao Cao, in the battle of Guandu, he could burn letters and buy people's hearts. Cao Pi's behavior seems too mean, Guan Yu and Sun Quan were not killed, and Cao Pi was so ashamed to treat a veteran who had worked for the Cao family for more than 30 years, it really shouldn't be, if you really want to kill and give death, why force death in such a vicious way.
Cao Pi's political problems and the tragedy of Yu Ban.
When Yu Ban came back, he was already gray-haired, and the sorrow can be imagined. Cao Pi comforted him after the ban and named him General Anyuan. Cao Pi didn't know how to kill the ban, because he had just ascended the throne, and killing the generals of the previous dynasty at this time was a bad signal. So throwing away the practice of finally nausing Yu Ban to death, Cao Pi did nothing wrong. It is normal to simply want to cure the crime of prohibition and establish a standard of prestige for the new imperial court. It's just that the practice is a little lacking in morality, so much so that Sima Guang commented that Cao Pi's measurement was too small.
Yu Ban: The Glory and Tragedy of General Cao Wei.
In the Wuziliang generals, the worst ending was Yu Ban, in the name of strict management of the army, the seized property was never hidden, so Cao Cao's reward for the ban was very heavy. In the twenty-first year of Jian'an, Yu Banqian was moved to the left general, and he was pretended to be a festival. Yu Ban is the only foreign surname general in Cao Wei's generals, but unfortunately Yu Ban is not guaranteed in the evening festival. Compared with Pound's refusal to surrender, Yu Ban's behavior is indeed a bit contemptible, but it is difficult to die through the ages. Survival is a human instinct. Nor can it be too harsh on the ban.
Cao Pi's political choices and consequences.
But what Yu Ban didn't expect was that he would be captured by Guan Yu and Sun Quan successively. When Yu Ban returned, Cao Cao had already died. After meeting Cao Pi, he was already a thing. If Cao Pi can not be reinstated as an official, he will naturally achieve a good story of monarchs and ministers. But Cao Pi specially drew a picture of Yu Ban surrendering Guan Yu and humiliating Yu Ban, which is worse than killing people.
Cao Pi's political wisdom and desire to compete.
The world is undecided, and it is the time to subdue the hearts of the people, and Cao Pi began to liquidate at this time. This kind of political level is really not high. If you look at it from the perspective of King Cao Pi himself, it is not surprising that there is a grudge against the ban. Yu Ban, who is already in his seventies, is no longer insignificant, and since he comes back, he will no longer be entrusted with heavy responsibilities, just retire for the elderly. If you want to give a heavier punishment, it is not impossible, the so-called "reward and punishment", if you do a good job, you should be rewarded, and if you do badly, you should be punished. But the problem is that Cao Pidu has already made an attitude of not being held accountable, but he humiliated the other party in a very undignified way afterwards. Don't forget the phrase "a soldier can be killed, but not humiliated", no matter how justified there is, humiliating a high-ranking general like this will inevitably make onlookers have other ideas. It's really a villain's act. Killing people is not enough, killing people is the most ruthless.
Cao Pi's gains and losses in governing the country and the tragedy of the ban.
Pound's actions were indeed loyal. That's why Cao Cao said, Yu Ban has followed me for thirty years, and he is not as good as Pang De. The reason why Cao Cao thinks so is because Yu Ban is positioned as a lonely minister, that is, Cao Cao's eagle dog. It can be that Zhang Liao, Zhang A, and Cao Cao will not say this if they surrender, but Yu Ban is different, once the eagle dog loses its loyalty, it will be useless. Yu Ban was loyal to Cao and was reused, and once captured, Yu Ban had only two good choices: suicide and death fighting, and once he surrendered, he was disloyal and unfilial. But the problem is that the superior can't let all his subordinates be like Pound, this approach is too harsh, Cao Pi despises Yu Ban, and he doesn't openly deal with Yu Ban. did not go to the level of the law, but he did not let go of the ban, but chose to humiliate him through an example like Li Pound, and let Yu Ban die himself. Yu Ban, as the "first general with a different surname" with outstanding merits, was captured twice but martyred, especially in the contrast of Pang De, if it is not disposed of, it will seem that Pang De would rather die than surrender is to die in vain, which is bound to have an impact on Cao Wei's political authority.
The political situation of the Cao Pi era and the helplessness of Yu Ban.
After Cao Pi ascended the throne, he completely blocked the way for eunuchs and relatives to participate in politics, strictly forbade the clan to interfere in politics, and cut off all his forces that might rely on life preservation but endanger the country. This also planted the seeds that were later replaced by the Sima family. There are entirely other ways to deal with the issue of banning. Cao Pi was too mean.
Summary: The tragedy of Cao Pi and Yu Ban.
Cao Pi's political decisions have left many controversies in the long course of history. For the handling of Yu Ban, it is necessary to establish the prestige of the new imperial court, and there is due respect for the meritorious heroes. Cao Pi may have failed to strike the best balance of political wisdom, leading to the tragedy of Yu Ban. This history makes us think deeply about the choices that leaders make between power and strategy, and the profound impact of these choices on nations and individuals.
This essay profoundly reveals the political disputes and human dilemmas between Cao Pi and Yu Ban, and brings readers to think about the behavior of historical figures. In the confrontation between Cao Pi and Yu Ban, the author presents Cao Pi's narrow-mindedness in political decision-making and unfair treatment of heroes through detailed historical details and sharp rhetoric.
Cao Pi's handling of the ban seems to lack due respect for the loyalty of heroes and years of military exploits, and more shows the side of political scheming. The article mentions that Cao Pi chose to humiliate the ban through an example like Li Pound, rather than taking a more decent way, so that the veteran, who had paid for the Cao family for more than 30 years, died in humiliation in his old age. This political method shows the cunning of Cao Pi's political decision-making and his over-infatuation with power schemes.
On the other hand, the article also has an understanding of the forbidden behavior. Although Yu Ban looked a little dwarf in comparison with Pang De, as the only foreign surname of General Cao Wei, he made significant contributions to the maintenance of military discipline and Cao Cao's appreciation. The loyalty and selflessness he showed fell victim to Cao Pi's political storm. This makes people deeply embarrassed, and they are deeply impressed by the ruthlessness of Cao Pi's political decisions and his disrespect for the heroes.
In addition, the article also points out some gains and losses in Cao Pi's political decision-making. After Cao Pi ascended the throne, he liquidated his political opponents while failing to strike the best balance between political power. His excessively harsh treatment of the ban not only manifested itself as a villain at the individual level, but also had a negative impact on the political authority of the entire country. Cao Pi's handling of the ban seems to have exposed some of his indifference to human nature, which made the political wisdom between power and conspiracy lose some humanistic care.
Overall, this article provides readers with a multi-dimensional historical observation through an in-depth analysis of Cao Pi and Yu Ban's political decisions and human dilemmas. Through this historical story, we can think about the choices that leaders make between power and humanity, and the profound impact of these choices on nations and individuals.
Disclaimer: The above content information is ** on the Internet, and the author of this article does not intend to target or insinuate any real country, political system, organization, race, or individual. The above content does not mean that the author of this article agrees with the laws, rules, opinions, behaviors in the article and is responsible for the authenticity of the relevant information. The author of this article is not responsible for any issues arising from the above or related issues, and does not assume any direct or indirect legal liability.
If the content of the article involves the content of the work, copyright**, infringement, rumors or other issues, please contact us to delete it. Finally, if you have any different thoughts about this event, please leave a message in the comment area to discuss!