Detective Di Renjie can be said to be the most successful detective drama, four in a row, each with a Douban score of more than eight points, breaking the curse that one series is not as good as the other, and it can be said that it has achieved a beginning and an end. After that, few detective dramas can achieve such high quality, and Tang Dynasty Tricks is one of the few.
Although they are both detective dramas, there are actually many differences between the two.
Detective Di Renjie is mainly Di Gong's detective, Li Yuanfang has been in the attached position as a super combat force, it is said that the adult is really a god Zeng Tai did not play a big role, Di Gong's official Di Chun is simply a sauce. To sum up the whole play, Di Renjie is in an important position, and the whole process of investigating the case is basically based on his own reasoning.
The Tang Dynasty is different. Di Gong's apprentice Su Wuming is not false as an IQ leader, but Lu Lingfeng is more important than himself. Lu Lingfeng is not only excellent in martial arts, but also delicate, arrogant and self-respecting but generous, although he is not as perfect as Li Yuanfang, but he can also be called a generation of heroes.
The role played by the divine doctor Fei Jishi has also made great contributions, not only is he a funny character in the entire TV series, but also used medical skills to save Lu Lingfeng in danger many times at critical moments, and it is not an exaggeration to say that he is the strongest assist. The heroine Pei Xijun is good at painting, and the case of the stone bridge picture brought her key clues. In a word, it is essential to have a detective team, and everyone is also very important.
In addition, the cases of Detective Di Renjie are almost all major cases related to the national economy and people's livelihood, and they are always complicated and unpredictable, such as the Youzhou case, which on the surface is the murder of the Turkic mission, and behind this is related to the Tang Princess's plan to overthrow Wu Zhou.
The Tang Dynasty Trick Records case has no family and country feelings so far. The mastermind of the Chang'an black tea case rose because of the hopelessness of his career, the mastermind of the Gantangyi case wanted to steal money, but the mastermind of the stone bridge pattern was unwilling to die of illness and tried to pull people back. Which theme is more attractive is a matter of opinion.
Of course, Detective Di Renjie is not without flaws, the analysis of the case flashbacks is lengthy, the reversal of many plots of the case shows routines, and every time the villain thinks he is winning, he will tell the conspiracy and the plate, Di Renjie will make a plan, turn defeat into victory, and win smoothly. If you see too much, the reversed accident will cease to exist.
In addition, Detective Di Renjie has a strong tendency to write in language, if it weren't for the deep line skills of Liang Guanhua and Zhang Zijian, ordinary actors would really not be able to control it.
But from the point of view of reasoning, it is obvious that Detective Di Renjie is even more powerful. Di Renjie's reasoning is almost meticulous, observant, logical, and indispensable. The real culprit that appears in the end is often surprisingly victorious, but it is reasonable. What's even more amazing is that almost all the reasoning is from director Qian Yanqiu, which is really a shocking work.
The reasoning of the Tang Dynasty's trickery cases was relatively coarse. Normally, in order to maintain the mystery of the plot, who is the real culprit can always be solved at the end, but in the Tales book, you can even deduce who is the real culprit if you can't even see the ending.
For example, the boss in the Chang'an black tea case is a wheelchair with inflexible legs and feet, and it happens that the county order is also faltering on the road, with obvious insinuations. The Huangmei murder case is easier to guess, almost all of the people who appeared on the scene died, only the beggar Donglang, the miscellaneous servant Jixiang, etc., there are many more shots given by Jixiang, he loves to read, and he also loves hunting, and the answer is self-evident.
Although it is slightly inferior in the reasoning of the judgment, the Tang Dynasty Mystery Record has its own uniqueness. The plot progresses quickly. At present, only 20 episodes have been broadcast, but the fifth episode is about to be declassified, almost an average of 4 episodes to solve the case, and a lot of trivial descriptions can be omitted in the middle, and there is no water injection at all, which is very enjoyable to watch. As far as the service is concerned, the Tang Dynasty Trick Tales have also made great progress than Di Renjie, which is beautiful and moving, with the texture of a film.
In a word, these two plays are very wonderful detective dramas. The person who has to choose one to win is naturally Detective Di Renjie. However, the arasodic story has only been broadcast for half an episode, and the plot may be more brilliant after that, and this judgment is likely to fail. In a word, the Tang Dynasty Trick Tale is undoubtedly the best costume drama recently, and there is no one.