Introduction: From July to December 219 AD, a historic battle took place in the Xiangfan area, Guan Yu, the general of the Five Tigers of Shu, led 30,000 elite soldiers, but was finally besieged by Cao Cao and Sun Quan, resulting in Guan Yu's death. This defeat not only caused Liu Bei's group to lose its top generals, but also caused the three counties of Jingzhou to fall into the hands of Sun Quan, bringing heavy losses to Liu Bei. If Guan Yu wins in Xiangfan, will it be good or evil for Liu Bei?
If Guan Yu wins the battle of Xiangfan, there will be 4 uncontrollable scenes in the whole world!
The first type: Cao Cao broke off with Guan Yuen during his lifetime If Guan Yu can defeat Xu Huang, Cao Ren will be defeated and occupy the Xiangfan region, but the three counties of Nanjun, Lingling, and Wuling will be difficult to defend. Sun Quan already possessed these cities, and Guan Yu was in a dilemma. Facing Cao Cao, Guan Yu needed to fight to the death, but he needed time to consolidate his position and could only defend Xiangfan. Guan Yu will send additional signal troops to find Liu Feng Mengda, and at the same time ask Liu Bei for support, Cao Cao will inevitably clash with Guan Yu, and the situation will be difficult to control.
The second type: Sun Quan took the opportunity to attack Xiangyang Sun Quan occupied the three counties of Nanjun, Lingling and Wuling, although the battle was victorious, but his ambitions did not stop there. Waiting for Guan Yu to engage Cao Cao, Sun Quan will take the opportunity to send troops to capture Xiangyang and form a tripartite slaughter. It was difficult for Cao Cao to directly oppose Sun Quan after reaching an agreement with him, but how Cao Cao responded to Sun Quan's ambitions became the key, and the situation was complex and difficult to grasp.
The third type: Liu Bei supported Guan Yu, the internal contradictions of Shu intensified, although Guan Yu occupied Xiangfan, it was difficult to hold, Cao Cao and Sun Quan were attacked, and Guan Yu's situation was worrying. Liu Bei faced internal and external pressure, so he could only send troops to support Guan Yu. Liu Bei's main force in Hanzhong suffered a lot of damage, but the obligation of Taoyuan's rebellion made it impossible for him to sit idly by, so he marched east to support. Cao Cao will not let Liu Bei go easily, Sun Quan will also take the opportunity to fight back, the internal contradictions of Shu Han intensified, and the three alliances in Taoyuan have become a stain on history.
Fourth: Liu Bei did not move, Guan Yu broke through to Sichuan and Shu, causing internal turmoil Liu Bei did not receive news from Jingzhou, Guan Yu successfully occupied Xiangfan, but could not hold it. The internal wisdom of Shu, such as Zhuge Liang, proposed that Liu Bei not move, stimulating Guan Yu to rush back to Sichuan and Shu. If Guan Yu succeeds in breaking through, his questioning of Liu Bei will lead to internal contradictions. Liu Bei had to support Guan Yu, but Cao Cao and Sun Quan would also work together to deal with Liu Bei, and the situation was in crisis.
The fifth: Guan Yu held Xiangfan, and a year later led the troops to attack Cao Wei, and if Guan Yu successfully held Xiangfan, he led the army to attack Cao Wei after a year of rest, forming a new pattern. Liu Bei supported Guan Yu, Shu Han fought Cao Wei, and Sun Quan may have given up the fight for Jingzhou. Cao Cao is deceased, Cao Pi has not yet stabilized the situation, and Shu Han may have the opportunity to support the Han family. However, the victory or defeat of Shu Han is unpredictable, and the situation in the world changes again.
This battle of Xiangfan, if Guan Yu wins, will trigger five uncontrollable scenes in the world, the plot is confusing, and the situation turns a thousand times.
The Battle of Xiangfan, this article vividly depicts the possible consequences of a hypothetical Guan Yu's victory by constructing five different scenarios, allowing the reader to gain a perspective on history"Hypothetical scenario"Thinking and imagining. These five scenarios will be commented on below.
First of all, through the assumption of the relationship between Cao Cao and Guan Yu, the article puts forward the scenario of Cao Cao's severance with Guan Yuen during his lifetime. In this scenario, the confrontation between the two strategic masters will inevitably stir up waves and turn the Xiangfan area into an uncontrollable melee situation. However, it also makes the reader think about Guan Yu's strategy in terms of power schemes, and the contradictions that he and Cao Cao may have erupted in this moment.
Secondly, the plot of Sun Quan taking the opportunity to attack Xiangyang highlights Sun Quan's ambition and strategic vision. This idea made Xiangyang the focus of the tripartite contention, with Cao Cao, Sun Quan and Guan Yu standing on three legs, and the situation was complicated. The scenario raises questions about how Sun Quan was cautious in navigating the complex diplomatic landscape, while also considering his relationship with Cao Cao.
In the third scenario, Liu Bei's support for Guan Yu led to the intensification of internal contradictions in Shu, showing an assumption of Liu Bei's wisdom and decision-making. Through the skillful use of the emotional bond of Taoyuan's righteousness, Liu Bei successfully inspires Guan Yu's loyalty and righteous indignation, but he falls into internal contradictions, laying hidden dangers for the future of Shu.
In the fourth scenario, Liu Bei did not move, and Guan Yu rushed back to Sichuan and Shu, which made the article further deepen the contradictions within Shu. This idea highlights the authenticity of Taoyuan's three knots in the predicament, and at the same time, it also makes people full of expectations and anxieties about the future of Shu Han.
In the last scenario, Guan Yu held Xiangfan and led his troops to attack Cao Wei a year later, bringing a new situation to the whole world. This assumption makes the article incorporate the ** of historical development, the rise of Guan Yu will bring new variables to the world, and Shu Han may have the opportunity to support the Han family, injecting some dramatic elements into the whole story.
Overall, the essay vividly illustrates the many different consequences that Guan Yu's victory can bring, through its clever conception of historical scenarios. Such an assumption not only enriches the diversity of historical stories, but also arouses readers' thinking and imagination about the possibility of historical events.
Disclaimer: The above content information is ** on the Internet, and the author of this article does not intend to target or insinuate any real country, political system, organization, race, or individual. The above content does not mean that the author of this article agrees with the laws, rules, opinions, behaviors in the article and is responsible for the authenticity of the relevant information. The author of this article is not responsible for any issues arising from the above or related issues, and does not assume any direct or indirect legal liability.
If the content of the article involves the content of the work, copyright**, infringement, rumors or other issues, please contact us to delete it. Finally, if you have any different thoughts about this event, please leave a message in the comment area to discuss!