Recently, an interesting entry quietly rushed to the hot search:
Chinese-style horror
Click on it and take a look, but I didn't expect it to be a controversy about the immersive sitcom "See Pingyao Again".
The main reason for this is a performance calledChoosing a wifefragments.
The actress with a beautiful face danced her hands on the stage, and strict standards sounded next to her:
If the feet are three-inch golden lotus, the palm print must not be broken, and the buttocks must be plump.
It's chilling.
Besides. Many people said that it was even more uncomfortable for the actress to writhe on stage with her clothes exposed.
As a result, the presence of other clips on the network was raisedConsumers humiliate womendiscussion.
Why was a show that had been staged for ten years suddenly pulled out for trial?
Today, let's talk about it.
See Pingyao Again was released in 2013.
As an immersive large-scale sitcom, it has always been well received because of its good experience.
First, the performance will be in the last years of the Qing DynastyThe story of Jin merchants, showing a very sense of substitution.
The second is that this performance is really eye-catching.
Two of the most classic fragments in it:Choosing a wifewithThe dart master is dead bath
The former is fragrant. The wrists are white and red, and the fingers are like peeled onions.
Apricot eyes are horizontal, and the eyes are cut autumn water.
The waist bulge is slender, and the willow swings slowly.
The plump buttocks are warped, and the folding fan can't be dropped.
The latter has a feeling. A sturdy male dart master washes his body in a 360-degree transparent tub.
Flowing droplets of water run across the muscles that symbolize strength.
Such a scene made many netizens jokingly call it China's ownCrazy Horse ShowwithMagic Mike
At first, such a large number of scenes showing the actors' bodies did not cause much controversy.
But later, some viewers began to question:Is it necessary for the actors to wear so little?
Especially the clip of Choosing a Wife.
The story is that the owner of a ticket number decided to go bankrupt to save people in Tsarist Russia, which moved the people of Pingyao and decided to choose a wife for him who had not yet married.
So they launched their own daughters and sisters.
The two parties who got married are obviously serious families, and the girls are also yellow flower girls.
But on the stage, the actress has to wear a belly pocket and twist her waist and hips on stage.
Moreover, the strange feudal standards of what the palm must not have broken lines, the navel must be good-looking, and the buttocks are rich and talented, are actually expressed in a fragrant form.
Is this really reasonable?
No matter how you look at it, it looks like a way to win attention by consuming women's bodies.
Plus, there are people online toMale ** profitThe name defines this episode.
It has aroused the discomfort of many people.
In fact, in the early days of "See Pingyao Again", it caused controversy because of these scenes.
At that time, the statement was mainly about whether or not to ** this point.
Later, someone wrote an article in a rowto denounce "See Pingyao Again" for using soft pornography to insult Jin Shang
He also said that the so-called "wife selection criteria" in it have no historical basis at all, and it is a kind of malicious fabrication.
It is not the first time that the same thing has happened to the director of the play, Wang Chaoge.
In her latest immersive sitcom "Only Henan Drama Fantasy City", there is such a paragraph:
The women of Lijia Village wore belly pockets and grabbed steamed steamed buns while saying, "I have steamed steamed buns."
This plot, like Choosing a Wife, has left many viewers puzzling.
Of course, there are also differing opinions on these controversies.
Some people seem to be such a showIt's just an expression, not an edge
So, where is the boundary between artistic expression and pornography?
This reminded Uncle Yu of the controversies on Yang Liping.
Her dance dramas "Peacock" and "The Rite of Spring" were both criticized by netizens because of the performers' costumes and the too intimate movements between male and female dancers.
However, those so-called "immoral" ** are just some one-sided, filmed from special angles and special times.
In order to earn traffic, some marketing accounts deliberately code the private parts of male dancers, creating an illusion.
Yang Liping also answered from the perspective of dance art itself.
The intimate scene in "Peacock" is to use the ultimate body language to present the life and death of the peacock
That dance was the favorite and the hardest.
There are no other decorations, and the actors need to perform with extreme body and body language.
In fact, if you've watched that dance, you won't feel any lewdness or ** at all.
Yes, it's just the power of natural life.
But what about "See Pingyao Again"?
The woman writhing on the stage does not express more connotation, but echoes the narrator's sentence and sentence, creating a gaze that stays on the female body.
And this phenomenon is not uncommon in many film and television works.
At the beginning of this year, Zhang Yimou's film was also mired in the controversy of "consuming women and insulting women".
The portrayal of several prostitutes in "Man Jianghong" is the messy hair and inappropriate clothes, which are accused of being sexual.
This is not the first time Zhang Yimou has been said.
I don't think anyone can forget the rows of full that are about to overflow the screen in "Full of City".
Think about it, while such a picture expresses that women are the objects that carry the emperor's desires, it also greatly causes strong visual stimulation to the audience off the screen, achieving a kind of ** spectacle.
Moreover, the latter is more obvious.
Now when it comes to this movie, it seems that there is only so much left to think of.
In Uncle Yu's view, whether it is erotic rubbing or artistic expression, the audience's reaction is the most intuitive.
It's like the nude scene of flight attendant Whiting in "Dark Glory" at the beginning of the year.
Even if the actor specifically explained this nude scene afterwards:
Just did the necessary work and played the role required for the necessary part.
But the deliberate response itself proves that this clip has become a demand for people to watch dramas.
and Xu Qing in "Evil Does Not Prevail Over Justice".
The special buttocks display and the special crisp chest shots have become the points that people are talking about about this movie.
As for "See Pingyao Again".
Choosing a wife and taking a bath has become its keyword and publicity stunt.
Of course, this does not equate to pornography.
YesNot necessarily existing
At the end of the day, it's just for the sake of attracting attention.
At this time, if you look back at the words that call it welfare, the meaning behind it does not need to be said by Uncle Yu.
However, erotic edging is not yet at the heart of the controversy.
In fact, the biggest problem with "See Pingyao Again" isIt's that its expression is skewed
There are quite a few people who say:
This is a story that happened in the late Qing Dynasty, and many of the depictions of women in the play are actually to criticize the mutilation of women by feudal dross.
Why choose a wife?
It is because it is necessary to ensure that the incense of a family cannot be broken.
And not only can it not be broken, but it must also have good incense.
That's why there are such strict conditions to select women.
It should be a tiresome and shameful thing to display women as blood-bearing objects.
However, you don't feel such emotions in the paragraph of "Choosing a Wife".
The only way to see is to show the female body in a curious and entertaining way.
Rather than criticizing, it is more about further glorifying the move.
And, one thing that is easy to overlook is:
The core of the story of "See Pingyao Again" is to promote the faith and righteousness in Jin culture.
But these are all men alone, and they are based on the sacrifice of women.
It's like the bridge section of the Dead Bath of the Dart Master.
What is a dead bath?Because these dart masters are going to embark on the road of saving people from the past, they must go on a clean road.
But the point of this bath is not washing, butRub
Next to each dart master's bathtub, there is a specially selected festive girl.
They have to wait for the dart master to wipe their bodies, and they have to be picked up so that these dart masters have a final "comfort" before they die.
When everything is over, the dart masters can leave heroically in the praise of everyone.
What about these girls?
In Uncle Yu's opinion, this is a cruel and inhumane female sacrifice.
But such cruelty was all dissolved in the ambiguous lights and staggered figures, as well as the mobile phones raised by bystanders.
What is good irony?
Uncle Yu had to mention Zhang Yimou again.
His early films still have many excellent works that criticize feudal bad Xi.
In "The Red Lantern Hangs High", it is through the folk custom of lighting the lamp to show the difficulty of feudal women.
There's nothing fancy about it throughout.
Instead, he used a calm and self-contained lens to record the changes of a woman in the courtyard of the deep house.
At the same time, through the creation of an atmosphere, it brings people a creepy pathetic and helpless.
It's like a pair of small hammers that knock on the feet, light but straight to the point.
Some time ago, the ** drama of domestic films was also complained by many netizens.
* The purpose of the existence of the play is to beExpressing the pain and fear of women being violated
But in many works, it is disgusting to turn it into a highlight.
The most typical example is "Saving the Suspect", which was released some time ago.
It is clear that the man is committing the atrocity, but the camera is aimed at the victim.
It also provocatively swept the victim's bare legs and half-masked body from bottom to top.
and then forced the audience to witness the process of the victim being tortured and killed.
Directly willThe picture is erotic, and the scene is spectacle
From the ** in the story, such a shot is the biggest perpetrator.
At this time, let's go back to the opening Chinese horror.
Uncle Yu thinks that compared to the ghostly and terrible feudal customs.
Such a story that wraps the dross with entertainment and beautifies the pain with wonder.
is the real horror .
List of high-quality authors