Crossing the river in white: Lü Meng made the elite soldiers wear white clothes, pretended to be merchants to cross the river, captured the guards first, and captured Jingzhou. This is the historical story. Let's talk about what modern audiences think about this matter.
Both strategically and tactically, it is a rat, which seriously affects the status of future generations of businessmen, and it is equivalent to a fake Red Cross stabbing attack, violating the Geneva Conventions.
It is too much to take off your pants and fart Jingzhou's defense was empty at that time, and there were no soldiers and no generals, just attack Dongwu to cross the river in white can only say that the famous generals of the ancient times were cautious in their use of troops, and they didn't dare to be careless even if they knew that they would win.
Nanjun was originally lent to Shu Han by Eastern Wu, and crossing the river in white clothes was just to get back what he had lent.
From the perspective of the overall and long-term interests of the Three Kingdoms, it was a mistake for Eastern Wu to seize Jingzhou too early and destroy the Sun-Liu alliance.
The evaluation of Lu Meng is: I have learned some tricks and tricks, such as returning to Jianye with fraud and crossing the Yangtze River in white clothes, but I have not learned the eloquence and strategy of stabilizing the country.
What kind of behavior is fighting, Sun Tzu said at the beginning of the Art of War, Sun Tzu said: Soldiers, the major affairs of the country, the place of death and life, and the way of survival, must not be ignored. Fighting a war is not a matter of one person, it is about the country, and if you can't use the minimum price to kill or injure the greatest enemy's vital force, you are not a qualified general, and it is said that Ci is not in charge of the army, and an excellent general can give up his own soldiers, of course, he should give up his own reputation, as long as he can contribute to victory, it is worthy of recognition.
There is nothing wrong with the tactics, but strategically it can be called a backstabbing ally (after all, Sun Quan did not draw a clear line with Ji Han at the diplomatic level at that time), compared to the retrieval of Jingzhou, which is a quick excuse, combined with the internal performance of the Sun Wu regime, this military operation is largely to ease the contradictions within the family, but the effect is very limited.
On the army to conspire, then to cut the army, then to attack the army, under the siege of the city, Lu Meng crossed the river in white clothes, not to say that it is a war, how is it also a war, this is an obvious blowing point, but I ran into someone who should not be touched, and what bullshit businessmen are interested, and businessmen in the feudal era are also worthy of talking about interests?Besides, even if the businessman has interests, it was Liu Che who did it first, Lu Meng crossed the river in white clothes and died that is, he was a fake businessman, Liu Che's siege of Ma Yi was real, and the businessman should be a spy in the country, Shufen sprayed Lu Meng about this matter, can you talk to your ancestor Emperor Wu of Han first.
The tactics are good, but the strategy is not right. In terms of strategy, Zhou Yu is stronger than Lu Meng. In fact, the best time to annex Liu Bei was after the Red Cliff War, when the north was still in a chaotic period, and the flawless south looked south. It's a pity that Sun Quan didn't listen to Zhou Yu's words, which caused Liu Bei to become big and lose the opportunity to dominate the south. After the Battle of Yiling, Sun Quan still did not have the strength to annex Liu Bei, and at this time the north had been unified. If Cao Pi had conquered Wu in the south during the Battle of Yiling, it was very likely that he would have unified the whole country. Some people may say that the strategy is okay with the matter of Susukou, but in fact, Sun Quan realized this problem after the Battle of Yiling. You can resist the two attacks once, but it doesn't mean that you can resist two or three times. That's why they sent people to take the initiative to sue for peace, and there was no war in Wushu in the next forty years
To achieve the greatest victory at the lowest cost, Sun Tzu's Art of War is cloudy: a soldier who surrenders without a fight. The good of the good, too. Definitely a great battle.
Zhu Yuanzhang: "Defeat the enemy is brave, and victory is planned." In the past, Guan Yu was 10,000 enemies, which was broken by Lu Meng, and he had no plan, so he should be deeply guarded. ”
Chen Shou: Lu Meng is brave and scheming, knows the military strategy, Hao Pu, captures Guan Yu, and is the most wonderful. Although he killed lightly at the beginning, he finally deny himself, and he has the weight of a national soldier, and he is just a military general!
Chen Shou: Yu is kind to the soldiers and proud of the scholars. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both called the enemies of ten thousand people and are the world's tiger ministers. Yu reported to Cao Gong, Feiyi explained Yan Yan, and had the style of a countryman. Ran Yu is rigid and self-conscious, violent and ungraceful, defeating with shortness, and rational numbers are often also.
Instructor: Guan Yun generally does not understand the united front, this person is not very clever, and he treats the allied forces with a closed-door doctrine and does not pay attention to policies.