Pull a hair and move the whole body, and fall a son and be full of life. ”What this means is that any small decision can affect the final development of things. Especially in the years of ancient wars,The situation of the whole world is often changed by a small decision of the princesWhen the princes regretted it, they could no longer play any role, and could only silently suffer the consequences of their decisions.
Take the Three Kingdoms period as an example. In the battle of troubled times,Those in power will always consolidate their power by "settling the tyrants"., but what if those people didn't die?If the superior had changed his decision at that time, maybe the outcome would have been different.
For example, the three people who could not be killed during the Three Kingdoms period that netizens said before were killed by Sun Quan, Guan Yu killed one, and Cao Cao killed one。And these three people were "merciful" at that time, and they might be able to win more benefits for themselves.
First of all, Sun Quan killed one personNaturally, it is Guan Yu, one of the five tiger generals of Shu Kingdom。We might as well analyze it after Sun Quan killed Guan Yu, what was gained, and what was lost？In addition, if he didn't kill Guan Yu, what kind of benefits would it have for him or the Soochow Group.
In terms of territory, Guan Yu's death means that at least half of Jingzhou's land has fallen to the name of Eastern WuThis was very beneficial to Soochow's conquest of the world
More importantly, at that time, the state of Shu was powerful, Liu Bei took the remnants of the defeated army to unite Sun Wu in the future, and when he left, he happily integrated the soldiers and horses to go to Yizhou, and its development momentum was extremely scary.
Under such circumstances, Sun Quan killed Guan YuIn fact, it also balances the power balance of Cao Cao, Liu Bei, and Sun Quan
Cao Cao was defeated and returned to the north, and he no longer had the ability to go south in a short time. If Liu Bei is allowed to become bigger,Sun Wu's side is likely to face the threat of Shu directly
"The world is bustling, all for profit;The world is crowded, all for profit. ”Former allies could also be future enemies, so there was nothing wrong with Sun Quan's strategy of attacking Jingzhou. It's just that after killing Guan Yu, Sun Quan has to face Liu Bei's revenge, which is very uneconomical
Although in the Battle of Yiling, Lu Xun burned 700 company camps and let Liu Bei return, but the battle between Sun Quan and Liu BeiIt will inevitably make Cao Cao profit from it
On the other hand, Sun Quan only attacked Jingzhou but did not kill Guan YuThere is a good chance that the outcome will be different
Why did Liu Bei gather a large army to avenge Guan Yu?This is because of the deep relationship between Guan and LiuIt is quite a revenge and does not avenge the meaning of a gentleman
If Sun Quan doesn't kill Guan Yu, after capturing Guan Yu aliveUse Guan Yu and Liu Bei for land and resources, can Liu Bei agree?Whether it is from personal emotions or taking into account the three armed forces,Liu Bei had to agree
At that time, what if Guan Yu is unhappy?It is impossible for Liu Bei to fight him again. In ancient times, he was famous for his master, so he could only endure it, wait for a few years, and then find a reason for Guan Yu to fight back.
Several years of development, with the blessing of land, resources and populationSun Quan could have consolidated the defensive line around Jingzhou。Boss Liu will either compromise or lose with himself, waiting for Cao Wei to reap the benefits of the fisherman
Therefore, Sun Quan did not kill Guan YuIt's all good and harmless
Later generations analyzed that Sun Quan was afraid of Guan Yu's military ability, which was only one of the reasons for killing Guan Yu. Compared with Guan Yu himself, isn't the Shu army under Liu Bei more terrifying?
Sun Quan killed Guan Yu,Mostly for demonstrationsto show the strength and courage of Soochow to the world. It's just that he doesn't understand,Yue Wang Goujian lay down and tasted courage for three years to swallow the world, what about forbearance yourself.
Secondly, Guan Yu killed one personThat is, Pang De, who was killed in the Battle of Xiangfan.
This person was originally a military general under Ma Teng, and made a lot of contributions in the process of Ma Teng's expedition to the east and the west. Cao Cao coerced the Son of Heaven to order the princes and summoned Ma Teng to Xu Du as a guard captainPound followed Ma Chao to do things
Later, Ma Chao was defeated and attached to Zhang Lu and finally chose to surrender to Liu BeiPang De was grateful for Cao Cao's appreciation and took refuge in Cao Cao
On the battlefield of Xiangfan, Guan Yu showed great might, not only beating Cao Wei's famous general Cao Ren so much that he didn't dare to fight backeven used the tactic of going out of the encirclement point to send reinforcements, so that Yu Ban, who rushed to support, was also wiped out
When it came to catching Pang De, Guan Yu looked at Ma Chao's face and wanted to give Pang De a chanceAs a result, Pang De refused to surrender and was beheaded by Guan Yu to set an example
As far as the decision made by Guan Yu at that time is concerned, it is for or againstNone of that is wrong
You must know that when Zhuge Liang first came out of Qishan, he also beheaded Ma Jian with tears. The officers and men of their own army can still be executed according to the discipline of the army, but a surrendered general cannot be killed
It's just that Guan Yu didn't expect it because of his decisionIn the end, all the descendants of the Guan family were killed by the descendants of Pound
It was recorded in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Guan Yu": Pang Dezihui, although Zhong and Deng Vashu, Shu broke and wiped out the Guan family.
It means that Pang De's son Pang will follow Zhong Hui and Deng Ai to crusade against Shu and defeat Shu after the Shu State is defeatedPang Hui quietly looked for an opportunity to kill all of Guan Yu's family members left in Chengdu
So does Guan Yu have another choice?The answer is simpleArrest people and send them to Liu Bei
Not to mention that Boss Liu's means of winning over others are better than Guan Yu's, just look at Ma Chao's faceGuan Yu's decision can also sell the other party's favor
Although Ma Chao's character is not very good in the history of the Three Kingdoms,But as long as he sent it, he accepted it。What's more, Guan Yu didn't have to kill Pang De, and the enemy general was executed in the ancient warThe first is to boost morale, and the second is to deter the other side
To put it mildly, it didn't matter whether Pound died or not. As long as Guan Yu is willing, what if he is released?In terms of Cao Cao's suspicious character, Cao Cao still dares to use Pang De?
Of course, these are all conclusions that we, as posterity, have analyzed from the perspective of God.
Guan Yu kills or not, it's not wrongJust to say he can do better。Let Pound live, you can do more things that are beneficial to yourself and the development of Shu, why not.
But if you really don't kill Pang De, Guan Erye doesn't look like Guan EryeIt can only be said that in ancient and modern things, there must be gains and losses, and it is difficult to have the best of both worlds
In the end, Cao Cao killed a person, and the person Cao Cao killed was neither a general nor a strategistBut he has a decisive influence on the development of the entire Three Kingdoms and even the entire Chinese civilization, and he is Hua Tuo
Because of him, for the first time in the history of Chinese medicine, the method of anesthesia and then surgery was used to anesthetize the patient's whole bodyBecause of him, the scope of surgery in China has been unprecedentedly expanded;It is also because of him that China has appeared for the first time in a unique sport**-Five Fowl Opera
But why did Cao Cao kill Hua Tuo?
The reason is very simple, after Cao Cao's headache attack,Hua Tuo proposed the idea of craniotomy。In Cao Cao's eyes, this seemed to be to say to himI'll kill you first, and then I'll bring you back to life.
The suspicious and ruthless Cao Cao naturally will not let Hua Tuo go。Assuming that he didn't agree, what if Hua Tuo directly anesthetized himself and sat on the craniotomy surgery?Although he has a headache, he doesn't want to be Hua Tuo's test yet.
In fact, Cao Cao knew that Hua Tuo's medical skills were superb, and he also knew that he couldn't keep Hua TuoBut he never wanted Hua Tuo to give it to others。This is not to say that Cao Cao is childish, but his character has always been like this.
After accidentally killing Lu Bohao's family, he killed Lu Boyao on the way back from buying wine. Rather teach me to bear the world, and stop teaching the world to bear me。Such a Cao Cao, how could he allow Hua Tuo to help others.
What's more, many small things that happened to Cao Cao in the past also proved that he did not have any guilt for killing others.
One is that he was afraid that the people around him would harm him, so he pretended to kill a servant in his sleepHe blamed himself and said, "I killed someone in my dream".
The second is that after killing the grain officer Wang Yuan to calm down the army's heart, he said to himself:Your wife and children, I will help you take care of them
As for how Cao Cao took care of Wang Yuan's wife and children, as far as his ideological attitude of despising human life is concerned, it is also destined that Hua Tuo will be killed after he cannot be used by him.
But Cao Cao didn't expect itHua Tuo is really the first doctor in the world, or the kind that no one can replace
Wait until the headache recursOther doctors could only follow the prescription left by Hua Tuo to treat Cao Cao's illness, want to **, it's not realistic at all.
Not only that, when Cao Cao's favorite son Cao Chong fell ill, Cao Cao visited famous doctors to Cao Chong**. As a result, the public word of mouth is unanimously agreedOnly Hua Tuo has the potential to be good Cao Chong, this will not be rectified by Cao Cao again.
I knew that his ability was so strong at the beginning, so why kill him. Even if it's just captivityYou can also use Hua Tuo's family to threaten him and let him give it to his children or his soldiers
There is no regret medicine in the world, when Sun Quan, Guan Yu, and Cao Cao killed the corresponding characters, they were destined to bear the corresponding consequences. But even if history repeats itself,I believe that they will definitely make the same choice
Just like the tears mentioned above, Zhuge Liang was reluctant to kill Ma Jian even though he was reluctant to kill him. Otherwise, all the soldiers are Xi to being outside, and they will not obey the orders of the minister, then how to fight this battle, and whether the Han family will be restored?
It is worth mentioning that the final result may not be different depending on the choice. In the long history of development, everyone has tried to change their lives against the sky, but except for a very small number of people to show their styleThe vast majority of people just go with the flow
The only thing we can do nowIt's just that after analyzing the right and wrong choices of predecessors more rationally, we should carefully deal with our own choices in our future lives。Only in this way can history books truly play a role in bringing enlightenment and educational significance to future generations.