On July 6, 2007, the lights in the Gulou District People's Court of Nanjing City flickered, and a number of ** people gathered, and their eyes were all focused on a young man in the defendant's seat!
I saw that the young man's eyes were red, and he said with his fists clenched"I didn't hit the old man, I just kindly helped her! ”
But the judge sitting on the bench didn't seem to care about what the young man said, but replied"You didn't hit it, why did you help it? ”
The judge's words immediately caused an uproar, and all major networks have discussed it, and people have not asked such a question, that is, do good deeds and deeds, and now have to bear legal responsibility?
So speaking of which, I believe many people should have guessed it, what I said above is the shocking "Peng Yu case", and the sentence "You didn't hit it, why did you go to help?" "It is true that the judge is the judge of the own trial!
More than ten years have passed, and the impact of this case has not been eliminated, so how are the parties of the year doing now?
Let's take a closer look at the whole process of this case and see if Peng Yu knocked down the old lady back then!
At the 2014 Spring Festival Gala, comedy stars Shen Teng and Ma Li co-starred in a sketch called "Help or Not", which immediately aroused heated discussions from all walks of life.
Because the main thing about this sketch is that when you meet an old man who accidentally falls down on the road, will you go up and help the other party up?
If it is placed in the past, people's first reaction must be to help, not to mention the traditional Chinese culture of respecting the old and loving the young, that is, a person's most basic social morality will require themselves to do it.
But it wasn't until after the incident in 2006 that he picked up the old man who fell to the groundIt has risen from personal moral quality to the level of national legal responsibility! That's why this sketch appeared.
On the morning of November 20, 2006, Mrs. Xu, who lives in Nanjing, came out of her niece's house very leisurely, carrying a thermos flask and a handbag.
Because there was enough time, although Mrs. Xu walked slowly, she didn't pay attention to the situation under her feet, so she slowly came to the No. 83 bus stop.
At this time, some passengers waiting for the bus also gathered on the bus platform, and after the elderly came to the platform, some people also deliberately gave up a little space to avoid crowding into the old man's house.
After waiting for three to five minutes, a No. 83 bus came from the intersection in front of it and drove slowly into the bus stop.
At this time, after Mrs. Xu saw the bus coming, she involuntarily moved a few steps to the front, and at this time, the bus finally stopped and slowly opened the upper and lower doors.
After seeing the door open, the passengers next to them lined up and walked on the bus one after another, including an old man named "Chen Erchun". Just as Uncle Chen was about to get into the car, he suddenly heard a tragic wail, "Oops! Oh my legs! ”
According to Uncle Chen's own later description of the scene, we probably learned about such a process, because Uncle Chen himself has been emphasizing that he was only paying attention to the bus at that time, so he didn't know what was happening around him.
So when he heard the wail, he turned around and saw that Mrs. Xu had fallen to the ground, and the things she was carrying in her hands were scattered all over the ground.
Then Uncle Chen saw a young man walking briskly from not far away, and helped Mrs. Xu to the ground.
After seeing this scene, Uncle Chen couldn't help but nod in his heartI think that contemporary young people are still responsible, and when they encounter difficulties with the elderly, they will take the initiative to help.
And after Uncle Chen here saw the young man helping Mrs. Xu up, he hurriedly stepped forward to help, supporting the other side, and then helped Mrs. Xu to the platform to rest.
At this time, although Mrs. Xu was still crying out for pain, her consciousness was still awake, so after finding that she was helped up by others, she also slowly opened her mouth and said to Uncle Chen beside her.
Please call my son, the phone is in the bag, let my son come over, okay? ”
Hearing Mrs. Xu's request, Uncle Chen didn't say a word, took out a mobile phone from Mrs. Xu's bag, flipped through the ** number marked with the remark "son", and called.
Mrs. Xu's son is named "Pan Hui".He worked in the Eighth Division of Nanjing Municipal Public Security Bureau, Pan Hui immediately said that he would arrive immediately after receiving **.
Sure enough, not long after hanging up, Mrs. Xu's son Pan Hui came, and after checking his mother's injuries, Pan Hui first dialed 120 for first aid**, and then dialed 110 to call the police to file a case.
After the 120 ambulance arrived at the scene, Pan Hui took his mother Xu Laotian to the hospital, accompanied by the young man who helped Mrs. Xu up.
This young man's name is "Peng Yu", who works in a company in Nanjing, and after he helped Mrs. Xu up, he followed the ambulance to the hospital, and he also took out more than 200 yuan to pay for the old lady's medical expenses.
If this is the end of the matter, then in the eyes of the public,This will be a positive story of a young man who falls down on the road and helps an old man.
But is that really the case? After being hospitalized every day, an unexpected accident happened!
It was the young man who knocked me down, and when I was about to get into the car, I was hit by him! Mrs. Xu said to her son Pan Hui.
When Pan Hui heard this, he immediately became very angry in his heartNo wonder he came to the hospital with him and paid more than 200 yuan in advance for medical expenses, it turned out that he hit it!
Thinking of this, Pan Hui immediately contacted Peng Yu and asked the other party to bear all the losses, and also give his mother a certain amount of compensation!
Because the examination report of the hospital also came out at this time, the results were not ideal, and the old lady's injury was more serious, and the tibia was fractured.
If you want to be cured, even if the elderly have medical insurance, it will cost more than 20,000 yuan, not counting the later recovery costs.
So after hearing the doctor's words, Pan Hui immediately contacted Peng Yu, claiming that Peng Yu was required to bear all the expenses incurred during the period until his mother was completely **!
At this time, Peng Yu was also shocked after receiving Pan Hui's **, why did he kindly help your mother, but in the end he asked me to bear the medical expenses?
So Peng Yu refused at the time, and then hung up Pan Hui's **, but within two daysThe local ** sent a summons to Peng Yu, asking Peng Yu to go to the police station to make a record!
Not only that, but the only witness at the scene, that is, Uncle Chen Erchun, was also summoned to the police station and began to make records.
Let's first describe Peng Yu's situation, according to Peng Yu's own statement, that is, he got off the No. 83 bus that day.
When the door opened, he had already seen Mrs. Xu fall to the groundAfter seeing an old man lying on the ground, Peng Yu also hurried over quickly in three steps and two steps, and then helped Mrs. Xu up
After contacting the old lady's son Pan Hui, Peng Yu also went to the hospital together, and also paid more than 200 yuan in advance for medical expenses.
But for Peng Yu's statement, Mrs. Xu said that she didn't agree with it at all, because the truth was not what he said at all.
Xu Laotian claimed that he was about to get on the bus after seeing it coming, but Peng Yu happened to get off the bus at this time and hit him head-on.
Peng Yu knocked himself to the ground at once, and then hurriedly ran over to help himself, and asked me if I had medical insurance?
After hearing me say that there is medical insurance, he immediately said that if I want five five, then he will five five, and if I want nine, then he will admit nine.
Although his leg hurt at the time, he still thought that this young man was still quite sincere, so he didn't care so much.
For the two completely opposite statements of the parties,It is difficult to distinguish the truth from the fake for a while, and the testimony of witnesses will be crucial!
According to Uncle Chen, he was waiting for the bus at the time, so he didn't care about the things around him, so he didn't know how Mrs. Xu fell.
But Uncle Chen said again, but one thing he can be sure of is that it was at that timePeng Yu was still four or five steps away from where Mrs. Xu fell.
I clearly saw that it was Peng Yu who trotted all the way over to help Xu Laotian up, and he was still silently praising this young man in his heart at that time, with a sense of responsibility and responsibility.
From Uncle Chen's transcript, although we don't know the first half of the matter, we can clearly see the development of the second half of the matter.
If it is really according to what Uncle Chen said, then Peng Yu basically ruled out the suspicion of knocking down Mrs. XuBut such a crucial testimony turned out to be "magically missing" later!
In this regard, ** explained that it was because of the complicated documents in the police station, and later caught up with the "decoration", so it could not be found.
Therefore, after this incident spread, it immediately caused an uproar on the Internet, not to mention, the police department will file and classify each record.
Let's just say that the "decoration" of the police station will cause the loss of internal information, so a dereliction of duty will definitely not be able to escape!
But even so, the police department claimed that the testimony was missingThis will inevitably cause speculation from the outside world, and netizens believe that it must be the old lady's son who is doing something behind his back!
However, it can only be said that all this is just the speculation of netizens, and there is no substantive evidence at all, so the court still adopted the statement of the police station.
So in 2007, when this case was first instanced, the two sides disputedPeng Yu said very aggrievedly, "I just went to help her, and I didn't hit her at all!" ”
But in response to Peng Yu's statement, the presiding judge Wang Hao, a judge of the Gulou District People's Court in Nanjing, publicly replied, "You didn't hit it, why did you go to help?" ”
One sentence immediately "detonated" the entire network, this sentence made people feel very reasonable when they first heard it! Since you didn't hit it, why did you go for it?
Wang Hao suddenly became the target of countless netizens' verbal criticism, when does it take a purpose to promote traditional Chinese virtues? Isn't it okay to simply be a good person and do good deeds?
It can be said that Wang Hao's words immediately made the fallen old man rise from the issue of personal moral quality to the legal responsibility of the whole people!
The trial was adjourned because both parties failed to provide valid evidence, and not long after, the second trial of the first instance began.
In this trial, the court said that the testimony of the parties and witnesses had been confirmed to be lost, and asked both parties to provide new evidence.
At the same time, in this trial, Peng Yu also claimed that when he got out of the car, he did hit a person, but he was very sure that that person was not Mrs. Xu!
But Mrs. Xu seized this point and condemned Peng Yuclaimed that the person Peng Yu admitted to hitting was himself, and he just wanted to evade responsibility.
In this way, the second trial broke up unhappily again, and the court announced a temporary adjournment to wait for the third hearing, and on July 6, 2007, the third trial began.
And at the scene of this trial, Mrs. Xu's son Pan Hui actually provided a "key evidence" to the court in court, a piece of evidence that has been claimed by both ** and the court!
Pan Hui took out Peng Yu's first transcript! It's just that this transcript was taken by Pan Hui himself with his mobile phone, and it is not a paper document!
On this transcript, Peng Yu personally admitted that he knocked down Mrs. Xu, and Peng Yu questioned this on the spot!
Can these ** be used as evidence in court? And how many are they, which have been identified by the court as missing documents?
Similarly, Pan Hui's move once again aroused discussion from the outside world, which further deepened the outside world's speculation about Pan Hui's actions behind his back!
At that time, netizens speculated that it would be Pan Hui who took this transcript, and then picked out a part of it that was beneficial to him, and then provided it as evidence?
In this regard, Pan Hui and his family members said that it was impossible, and it was Peng Yu himself who admitted to knocking down the old man at that time!
But when things have developed to this point, whether it is Pan Hui or his relatives, it is still debatable how credible what they said.
However, at this time, Peng Yu said that when he helped the old man, Mrs. Xu once said such a sentence, "It will not affect you."
This point was confirmed by Uncle Chen after the court verified the eyewitness Uncle Chen Erchun, but Uncle Chen also stated it againI didn't know the process before the incident, I only saw Peng Yu go to help after she fell.
At this point, it is difficult to distinguish who is right and who is wrong, and the court refused Mrs. Xu's 1360,000 yuan in economic compensation, but the other side also thinks that Peng Yu needs to be held responsible!
So on September 3, 2007, the Nanjing Gulou District People's Court pronounced a verdict and demanded that Peng Yu compensate Mrs. Xu 45,876$36 loss.
Once this verdict was announced, it not only caused dissatisfaction among Mrs. Xu and Peng YuEven netizens thought that the verdict was wrong.
Because in the current law, there is actually such a general principleThat is, "there is no doubt about the guilt".That is, as long as there is no substantial direct evidence that you are involved in the case, then you are innocent.
Like the famous "Simpson Wife Murder Case" in the United States, the defense lawyer successfully won the lawsuit through this, and there is no doubt about the crime!
However, in this case, the Nanjing Municipal Court did not comply with this ruleInstead, he adopted the attitude of "there is no doubt about the crime" and determined that Peng Yu needed to be held responsible!
So after getting the verdict, Peng Yu said that he would prepare all the evidence to continue to appeal, and he must return his innocence, for which he also resigned from his job!
Today there is an old man who is disrespectful, and he who is old and disrespectful to me. I don't want because of my case, people will not be willing to help the old man when he falls in the future. Peng Yu was very resolute when he spoke.
Because the social impact of this case was too widespread, after the parties continued to appealOn October 8, 2007, under the organization of the court, the parties began another mediation.
The content of the mediation is not known, but it is certain that after the mediation, both parties withdrew the lawsuit, and the court did not announce the amount of the mediation.
So far, this case has come to an end, but the case has come to an end, but the impact caused by it has not dissipated for a long time.
After the mediation of the case was completed, Peng Yu not only lost his job, but also lost his other economic **,So one day, Peng Yu canceled his original mobile phone number and other information.
A person left Nanjing, perhaps to return to his hometown, or to other cities, but since then there has been no news of him on the Internet.
And Mrs. Xu's family came over from time to time, most of them were reporters, and they wanted to interview Mrs. Xu, but Mrs. Xu, who couldn't stand the disturbance, finally moved out of Nanjing.
She sold her house, wrote off her family fix**, and her mobile phone number, and subsequently under her son's arrangementI went to live in another place.
As for Judge Wang Hao, who said, "You didn't hit it, why did you help him?" after this case, he was transferred out of the Gulou District Court and went to work in a sub-district office in Nanjing.
Although several parties to the incident have disappeared from public view in recent years, the impact of this case is very far-reaching!
This has also caused a serious social and moral crisis, and now, when the old man falls down on the road, perhaps not too many people dare to help!
This has to be said to be an inexplicable sadness, and in order to improve social trust, the state has been vigorously promoting Chinese virtues in recent years, and at the same time, some places have introduced relevant "good person laws" to protect the rights and interests of rescuers.
I only hope that with the efforts of ** and everyone, the adverse effects caused by this case can be eliminated as soon as possible and a harmonious society can be built together!
**10,000 Fans Incentive Plan