According to an article, Mr. Hu Qiaomu once proposed that "Qinyuan Spring and Snow" was his own work, and his signature should be restored.
In this regard, the **Party School and the Communist Youth League** either issued an article or a refutation. In one, the Communist Youth League listed this statement as one of the top ten rumors and reminded everyone to be vigilant.
Hu Qiaomu's daughter Hu Muying also said a sentence for this: "This poem was written by ***, my father can't write that spirit!" ”
So, was "Qinyuan Spring Snow" written by Hu Qiaomu?
Hu Qiaomu did write a work related to the "Qinyuan Spring" word card, but it was not "Qinyuan Spring, Snow", but "Qinyuan Spring: Hangzhou Feelings" published in 1964.
Hu Muying said that his father couldn't write ***'s courage. This is not modest, and a comparison of the two words shows that their styles are completely inconsistent.
Qinyuan Spring Snow is straightforward and easy to understand, angular, and full of masculinity; "Qinyuan Spring: Hangzhou Feelings" is obscure, quite euphemistic, and always feels lacking momentum. They are not the same style at all.
Can one write something in two styles? Some people believe it, but most people don't believe it anyway, unless that person's spirit ** or life is cut from it, and suddenly changes from one person to another.
The last sentence in "Qinyuan Spring, Hangzhou Feelings" still looks very bold - "Who is with me, dancing and leaning on the sky and the long sword, sweeping away this absurdity".
In fact, this sentence is the result of ***'s modification of the original sentence, and Hu Qiaomu's original manuscript is written - "Who is with me, roaring the wind and the sword, extinguishing this life".
This is only a stylistic analysis of whether "Qinyuan Spring and Snow" was written by Hu Qiaomu, and from the perspective of historical background, it is even more likely that he wrote it.
According to the data, "Qinyuan Spring Snow" was created in early 1936.
In February 1936, he led the Red Army to the East. At that time, it was snowing heavily in the northwest region, and the Loess Plateau was vast.
This situation and this scene made *** poetry flourish and improvised "Qinyuan Spring Snow".
There are two theories about where he works. One says that it is near Gaojie Village, Qingjian County, Shaanxi, and the other is that it is in the vicinity of Liucun, Shilou County, Shanxi, and there is no unified conclusion.
It is not excluded that such a possibility is written, ** in one place, and then revised in another place. After all, good works generally do not happen overnight, but have to be repeatedly revised and refined.
What was Hu Qiaomu doing during this time?
In 1937, after settling in Yan'an, he asked Hu Qiaomu and others to go to Yan'an. However, they stopped for a long time on the road and did not arrive in Yan'an until October 1938.
Later, Hu Qiaomu was assigned to "China Youth" as the editor-in-chief.
If he wrote "Qinyuan Spring and Snow" during this time period, it could have been published in "Chinese Youth", why not? There is only one answer, and it was not written by him.
Some people question, who said that the creation time of "Qinyuan Spring Snow" was around 1936, and other time periods can also be.
This question has already been answered.
In August 1945, ** came to Chongqing for negotiations. During this period, the famous poet Liu Yazi corresponded with him many times. Liu Yazi named and wanted "Seven Laws: Long March".
After thinking about it repeatedly, ** did not send "Seven Laws: Long March", but "Qinyuan Spring Snow". In the reply, ** said that it was written during the army's crusade.
This period coincided with the Crusade in February 1936. So, ** is the real author of this poem.
In addition, some evidence has long shown that "Qinyuan Spring Snow" was written by ***. Speaking of which, we have to go back to the analysis of style.
** "Qinyuan Spring, Changsha", "Remembering Qin'e, Loushanguan", "Water Tune Song Tou, Revisiting Jinggang Mountain", etc., are all domineering. Such a temperament cannot be imitated.
If Hu Qiaomu really wrote "Qinyuan Spring Snow", then why don't his other works have such momentum?
If you insist that this is Hu Qiaomu's genius, it is like a hot spot on the Internet recently. After Daolang's new song "Rakshasa Sea City" became popular, a man claimed on the Internet that it was a song he wrote, but there was no evidence.
On the other hand, he really wrote this song, so why is there only this one work and no other works?
Based on various theories, Hu Qiaomu's creation of "Qinyuan Spring and Snow" has no argument at all. In other words, this is a rumor with ulterior motives.
Nothing can be achieved overnight, and "becoming popular overnight" is just a flashpoint. In front of this flashpoint, some things have been brewing for a long time, and some people have also worked hard for countless days and nights.
As the proverb goes, "One minute on stage, ten years off stage." ”
It is impossible for anything to have no antecedents and brewing, and a result will come out all at once, except for the probability event of winning the lottery, nothing else is possible.