When Jiang Xiaoyun, who was only 9 years old at the time, did a good deed on the side of the road with his friends and helped an old man who had fallen, he realized that not everything is "good people have good rewards". [Listen to the song].
01 Good intentions are not rewarded.
On June 15, 2013, Jiang Xiaoyun and his classmates were walking home after school, but just as they were waiting to hurry home to finish eating and playing, they saw an old man sitting on the side of the road.
In line with the school's principle of caring and doing good deeds, these students immediately went forward to inquire about the situation, and then learned that the old man had fallen and might not be able to stand up due to his age.
So he and a few classmates decided to help the old man, and they directly stepped forward to help him up, which still took some effort for these children who were still in elementary school.
And just when they were still proud of the good things they had done, this aunt's words made them feel overwhelmed in an instant.
She dragged Jiang Xiaoyun directly, and then shouted loudly that he hit herself, so that they couldn't run, and they had to apologize and compensate themselves, followed by crying and fussing.
The other children didn't dare to say anything when they saw this scene, but fortunately they knew the address of Jiang Xiaoyun's home, so they immediately went to call their parents for help.
However, Jiang Pidong, who had just arrived at the accident site, saw the reactions of onlookers and aunts, and really thought that his child had knocked down the old man, and it was a lesson to the child, and told the aunt that there was something to say, let's go to the hospital first.
Jiang Xiaoyun, who not only did not receive thanks for doing a good deed, but was also innocently scolded by his father, was also very innocent in his heart, but even if he said that he didn't hit the person himself, and when he cried aggrievedly, he looked very pale in the crowd's onlookers and questions.
After arriving at the hospital, Jiang Pidong admitted that he had paid a sum of money for the old man's medical expenses, including some inpatient examinations, bone-setting medicine, and his own apology, which added up to about 1,000 yuan.
After returning home, he began to ask his son what was going on, but Jiang Xiaoyun insisted that he didn't hit it, and told the experience at that time completely, and under the persuasion of his wife, he began to waver a little in his heart, thinking if what his son said was true.
However, what he didn't expect was that when he himself was still in doubt, someone really came to the door and confirmed the fact that his son was falsely accused, that person was called Gong Hongchun, claiming to be the son of Mrs. Jiang who was hit.
I thought that he was here to understand the situation because his mother was hit, but he didn't expect that the other party was specifically here to find trouble, and as soon as he opened his mouth, his mother was hit, and a few thousand yuan was not enough at all, and he asked Jiang Xiaoyun and the parents of the other 3 children to compensate.
Jiang Pidong, who knew that he was at a loss, had no choice, so he and the other 3 parents decided to make a 10,000 yuan together, which was regarded as compensation for the elderly, but he didn't expect the other party to admit it at all, and bluntly said that the matter was not over without 1 million.
At this point, these parents can't see the problem anymore, that is, they are really stupid, combined with their children's previous statements, they also determined that the other party is here to slander people.
So they said that if the other party was in this situation, then they would not pay a penny, and they would call the police to deal with it, but Gong Hongchun said that he would sue them, anyway, he had a diagnostic report, and he was sure that there was no monitoring or anything like that at that time, so the matter reached an impasse.
02 It is difficult to distinguish between truth and falsehood.
When Jiang Pidong and the others were still very distressed because of this matter, they didn't expect the other party to be such a scoundrel, saying that if they didn't give money, they would use ruthless tricks, and directly carried the old man to his door, and then the mother and son directly stayed inside and didn't leave.
So the neighbors saw that they were making trouble every day, and in the early morning, Mrs. Jiang's mother and son were crying and abusing at the door, saying that the other party hit someone, not only did not lose money, but also abused the elderly.
In desperation, Jiang Pidong still asked the other party to hurry into the house, otherwise it would really make the people around him think that he did it himself, but he didn't expect that the mother and son stayed for 2 days, and the trouble was getting bigger and bigger, so he could only choose to call the police.
Of course, the arrival of the police was just to mediate, after all, it was not a court, and when it was not confirmed whether anyone on both sides had really committed a crime, they could not punish or arrest people at will, so they could only let Gong Hongchun take his mother home.
I thought that the matter was over for the time being, but I didn't expect that after a while, the other party ran to the Public Security Bureau with the physical examination report, and he had to let Jiang Pidong and others lose money.
They couldn't bear it anymore for these scoundrels to press on them step by step, but the other party had a hospital report as evidence, and on the other hand, there was almost nothing on their side except for the child's oral statement.
If this continues, I am afraid that such a crime will be confirmed by themselves for no reason, so they directly made a "missing person notice", hoping to find witnesses who saw the whole process at that time, and this trick proved to be really effective.
There were some people who liked to set up small stalls next to the school, and one of them was an aunt who happened to be in that position, and she saw with her own eyes the scene of the old man slandering these children.
But the human evidence is really too pale compared to the physical evidence, so Gong Hongchun insisted that the other party was invited by these parents, and the case fell into complexity again, after all, where can I find physical evidence for this kind of thing, and fortunately, this physical evidence really appeared.
When Jiang Pidong and others were worried, a stranger contacted him, saying that he had seen the missing person revelation he had posted, and he happened to have the ** at that time.
This gentleman himself is also kind, and when he saw Mrs. Jiang sitting on the side of the road, he wanted to step forward to help, but he himself was quite cautious, directly turned on the mobile phone to record the video, and then stepped forward.
What I didn't expect was that before I arrived, several children went over to help people up, and then the video was recorded in this way.
Originally, he thought that this slanderous matter might be dealt with after the parents came over, but he didn't expect the other party to make such a big fuss, so he expressed his willingness to take ** to testify in court.
This incident can be described as a rain from heaven for several families who have been tortured, and when this ** appeared in the court, Gong Hongchun's mother and son had nothing to say.
At the same time, even his wife stood up and directly said that the old man's injuries were not hit at all, but caused by a fall at home a few days ago.
But at this time, his mother, Mrs. Jiang, still refused to give up, insisting that Jiang Xiaoyun had hit herself, and said, "If I lie, the whole family will die." "But the evidence is ironclad, even if you swear poison, it's useless, let alone an oath made by **.
03 Whether to help or not.
At the end of November 2013, after the truth of the whole incident of "Jiang Xiaoyun and others supporting the old lady against being blackmailed" was revealed, the court also made a trial:
Mrs. Jiang was sentenced to 7 days of administrative detention for extortion, but because she was over 70 years old, she was not executed and was instead verbally criticized; Gong Hongchun was sentenced to 10 days of detention, fined 500 yuan, and returned his illegal gains.
The case is now completely over, but the impact of this incident is still not over, and there is still a great deal of dissatisfaction with such executions.
First of all, Mrs. Jiang did not carry out the final detention because she was too old, while Gong Hongchun only had 10 days of detention and a fine, which made people feel too light.
Many netizens think that the cost of such a crime is too low, if it is just so easy, the cost of crime for them will be too low, and it will inevitably cause more such situations, and there is a possibility of repeated crimes.
In fact, this is not the first time that such an idea has been made, and there have been many similar cases before this, such as the most sensational Peng Yu case in 2006:
The old man Xu Shoulan broke a bone after being hit on the bus platform, but it turned out that it was Peng Yu who had just gotten off the bus who hit her, and this incident also caused a lot of trouble, but the evidence was far more difficult to find than Jiang Xiaoyun's case, and finally lasted until 2012, and it was finally resolved under the coordination of all parties.
After that, there were many such cases, and at the same time, a question was born, that is, "to help or not to help?" And there are still many discussions on this topic, and even many works have been derived to satirize.
In our long-standing moral concept, "respecting the elderly, loving the young, and helping others" has always been a traditional virtue, so there is never a lack of initiative to help others when encountering people in need.
However, in recent years, all kinds of porcelain, blackmail or misunderstanding have occurred repeatedly, which makes people feel that sometimes it is not that they don't help, but that they really dare not help, and such ideas are also spreading more and more widely with the continuous development of such cases.
In fact, on the question of whether to help or not, I think Jiang Xiaoyun's expression after the incident is very correct: although this incident is very sad, but in the future, when someone needs help, he will still take the initiative to help.
This kind of thinking may also be the real thoughts of the vast majority of people when they really face this situation, after all, there is really no shortage of helpful situations like this around us.
But support is support, how to help? How can I help? It's a problem that needs to be considered, like being blackmailed as a result of being kind to help, and it is very common for normal actions to be touched.
Therefore, even when helping others, you must still be cautious, such as the person who gave **, take the initiative to turn on the camera to film the whole process of your actions, and protect yourself when you help others.
Of course, the contradiction about whether to help or not can not be solved by a single statement, after all, individuals have different experiences and feelings, and some people may have really been blackmailed and dare not make a move.
Therefore, to solve such a problem, it is still necessary to solve it from the source, and measures such as monitoring in various public places and strengthening the punishment of blackmail personnel can better reduce this kind of innocent "good intentions are not rewarded".
To this day, there are still many people who believe that there are many good people in the world, so it is precisely in this way that we should strictly prevent such situations from happening here, so as not to let good people not dare to do good deeds.
1] Porcelain Capital Public Security -
The elementary school student helped up the old man who fell and was falsely accused, and the insider stood up and detained and fined.
2] People**
The primary school student helped the old man to fall down, and was falsely accused of "reversing" ** Two children knocked the old man down.
3] Bright Net -
Elementary school students were falsely accused of helping the elderly, but fortunately, passers-by testified? ** Issued a bulletin, the truth turned out to be ......