2024 Spring Festival stalls
"South to North" ended last night, as a period drama, not only created a rating of 39922% of Kuyun's highest peak, and the single-day ratings reached 40335% broke the highest peak of Kuyun, crushing the top three "Thrush", "Hurricane" and "Fearless" of the Central Eight last year, which can be said to have achieved a double harvest in both its social effect and commercial value.
I thought that the show might be comparable to another period drama "The World", but now I look at it as worried that it has a bad ending (see clumsy: "South to North" is going to be unfinished?). The sign is that the plot is unreasonable and the male protagonist goes to extremes).
One of the proofs is the "Do you like the finale of "Do you like the finale" launched by a certain platform, and so far, as many as 55% of netizens have voted not to like it.
said that the show was unfinished, let's start with the three items on the show's hot list. One is "The tension of the train confrontation scene in "South to North" is full", which is about Jia Jinlong's confrontation with Ma Kui's master and apprentice with guns on the train.
In fact, this scene is completely a redundant and redundant play, and it is a play that should not be. Because Ma Kui got off halfway to go to the Hacheng Criminal Police Detachment, and Wang Xin specially called the police during the banquet, it is said that the public security should have made careful arrangements, but two of them ran away during the ambush, which questioned the ability of the criminal police to handle the case.
What's even more bizarre is that Jia Jinlong didn't use his own special car, but fled from Harbin City by train with two accomplices, isn't this self-defeating?
Of course, this is the choreographer's artificial preparation for the train confrontation below, and the foreshadowing for Ma Kui's sacrifice. Because Ma Kui said to Wang Xin in the hotel before, "You kid, you are also a teacher", as soon as the lines came out, it meant that Ma Kui was going to receive a boxed lunch.
The second is "Jin Chen's first attempt at elderly makeup". In the blink of an eye, the show is in 2017, and the amazing thing is that Wang Yongge is still alive, he should be about eighty years old, in addition to still being forgetful, he can still walk, it seems that Jin Chen, the daughter-in-law, has taken care of him really well, because there has been no development in the past 20 years. And Ma Yan, who was supporting Wang Yongge, should also be 56 years old at this time, well-maintained, with black hair and no wrinkles.
But when it came to sweeping Ma Kui's tomb, Ma Yan not only had age spots, but also had "snow" floating all over her head, what made her feel white "overnight"? Compared with Wang Yongli played by Wang Herun, although she is smaller than Ma Yan, she is full of mulberry. Therefore, Jin Chen's elderly makeup was not successful.
The third is not on the same list as the previous two, """South to North" Ma Kui is offline, Wang Xin is crying. In the play, Ma Kui is famous for his arm strength and wrist strength, and Wang Xin is in his prime.
As a result, when the two worked together to arrest Jia Jinlong and seize the gun, they actually let Jia Jinlong free his hand and give Ma Kui a knife. It's really shocking, sighing that Lian is quite old, and it is not okay to refuse to accept the old, and Wang Xin is even more panting like a cow, and the arrogance that turned out to be wrestling with the old man showed his original form when he really acted.
The choreographer really has you, and the life and death of the actor are in the hands of the choreographer. Are you portraying a hero's feat or reflecting the incompetence of the police? Ma Kui has worked all his life and made countless meritorious contributions, and he should have retired to enjoy his old age, but it ended in tragedy, and he made his family die blindly. The choreographer really dares to challenge the audience's bottom line! In fact, since you want to end in a hurry, you can capture Jia Jinlong's drug trafficking gang in Hacheng in one fell swoop, and you have to kill Ma Kui? No wonder the audience didn't like it.
In addition, from the perspective of service and plot development, the play has also been unreasonable many times. Just take the finale as an example, for example, in the nineties of the last century, drugs were mainly used to manufacture hero, which needed to be purified with acetic acid, so the finished products of *** had an obvious acetic acid taste, and the people who smoked *** would also have a strong sour smell.
Therefore, as Ma Kui, who specializes in exercising his sense of smell, there is no need to collude with Jia Jinlong's subordinates and deliberately smell on others.
For example, communication was not convenient and fast back then, how could that sheep herding baby be able to stay by the train track every time to accept the gift from Ma Kui as agreed?
And Cai Xiaonian is sixty years old, can he still be a train conductor? It's really hard, because the General Administration of Railways stipulates that the age of the high-speed rail conductor cannot exceed 45 years old, and he will be transferred after that.
The official announcement of "South to North" introduced that "it has witnessed the rapid development of China's railways from the era of steam locomotives, to the era of electric locomotives, and then to the era of bullet trains and high-speed railways", with a time span of 40 years. However, the series reflects the eighteen years from 1978 to 1996 (the time of the sacrifice of Ma Kui's tombstone), and less than one episode has been brought in the later episodes. Although Ma Kui is offline, there is still Wang Xin, where is the inheritance?
However, the play really has a legacy reflection. That is, Master Ma Kui was stabbed to death by a knife, and so was Ma Kui. Jia Jinlong and his brother made the same request during the confrontation with the police, asking the car to fill up with gas.
From the unreasonable direction of the plot to the hurried ending, it can be seen that the choreographer's ability to control the whole play, especially the ending, has shortcomings. But although the show is not as good as "The World", it is still worth watching.