Li Juan is a strong woman with an annual income of one million, and she has a house and a car under her name, but her emotional road is bumpy, and after divorcing her ex-husband, she is afraid to start a new relationship.
Until 2016, Li Juan, who had been divorced for many years, met Xiao Zhao, who was also divorced and single, under the introduction of a friend. Xiao Zhao is an ordinary person who can no longer be ordinary, with average work and average income, but he moved Li Juan with sincerity. After a period of time together, they have developed a deep relationship with each other.
Li Juan is a woman who is tough on the outside but fragile on the inside. She impresses with the strength and confidence she shows in her work, but she always struggles to show her true side when dealing with people. Xiao Zhao has an ordinary appearance and an ordinary life, and he always treats Li Juan with a warm and tolerant attitude.
They understand each other and support each other, although Xiao Zhao is not a successful person in the eyes of the world, but in the eyes of Li Juan, he is a priceless treasure. The power of love is great, it makes Li Juan bravely walk out of the shadow of the past and believe in the beauty of love again. After getting along for half a year, the two decided to join hands in whitehead.
On the day of receiving the certificate, the two got up early, they filled in the ** nervously and excitedly, and swore to each other to promise each other's love and loyalty. When they got the marriage certificate, the two hugged each other tightly, and Li Juan burst into tears, she felt that she had met true love.
After Li Juan and Xiao Zhao officially became husband and wife, the two were newly married Yan'er, and their relationship was very sweet. They live together in Li Juan's house, but this house is full of unpleasant memories of the past, and Li Juan thinks that since it is a new beginning, she will change the suite and start over.
After that, they looked at the house and chose the house, but Xiao Zhao's family background was average, and he couldn't get much money, but Li Juan slapped his hand, it doesn't matter, you just need to see if you like it or not, and I have the rest. She quickly disposed of her old house, used the money to pay the down payment on the new house, and they ordered a house of 10 million yuan. After the house was bought, the two moved in and started a new life.
However, the house did not bring the two the happiness they expected. After all, it is a combination of strong women and weak men, no matter how carefully Li Juan cares for Xiao Zhao's glass heart, Xiao Zhao always feels that Li Juan is too strong and does not have the gentleness of a woman. Because of the income gap, the consumption concepts of the two are also inconsistent, Li Juan can buy expensive gifts for Xiao Zhao, but Xiao Zhao has no way to give back. When the two repeatedly quarreled over trivial matters in life, they once again felt the importance of being the right person.
In June 2018, the two officially separated, and Xiao Zhao quickly moved out. After that, the two lived a life in name only, and they didn't contact each other and didn't care about each other. Li Juan felt more and more that such a marriage had no point in continuing, and she sued for divorce for the first time, but Xiao Zhao did not agree on the grounds that the relationship between the husband and wife was not broken, and the court did not allow the two to divorce.
In July 2021, Li Juan once again sued for divorce on the grounds of broken feelings, and asked to confirm that the property purchased by the two after marriage belonged to her. This time, Xiao Zhao agreed to the divorce, but he proposed that since the property was purchased after marriage, it belonged to the joint property of the husband and wife and should be divided. The divorce lawsuit between the two has attracted a lot of attention, and everyone is curious about what the final verdict will be.
Uncle Ho's point of view:
1.The power of love is great, and Li Juan and Xiao Zhao's encounter and love for each other shows mutual support and understanding, and this emotion will make people feel warm and happy.
2.Li Juan's purchase of a new house before marriage indicates that she has a positive attitude towards a new beginning and is willing to make efforts and sacrifices for the sake of shared happiness.
3.Xiao Zhao's agreement to the divorce and his proposal to jointly divide the property purchased after the marriage shows that he has a responsible and fair attitude and is willing to resolve the differences in an equal and reasonable manner.
Grandma Song's point of view:
1.Li Juan was too aggressive when choosing a new house, ignoring Xiao Zhao's opinions and financial situation, which could lead to conflicts and dissatisfaction between the two, causing disagreements in life.
2.The inconsistencies in the concept of consumption between the two people, and the economic disparity led to a sense of imbalance in material things, which further exacerbated the conflict between the two.
3.Although Xiao Zhao agreed to the divorce, he advocated that the property should be the joint property of the husband and wife, which may have caused controversy and further exacerbated the conflict and contradictions between the two.
As a lawyer, I would like to give the following legal opinion on this case:
1.According to article 32 of the Marriage Law, divorce should be due to the fact that the relationship between the husband and wife has broken down. Li Juan filed for divorce on the grounds of relationship breakdown, and Xiao Zhao also agreed to the divorce, which was in line with the law.
2.On the issue of ownership of real estate, according to Article 43 of the Marriage Law, the ownership of immovable property purchased by one of the spouses with personal property shall be vested in the individual. The 10 million-level house mentioned in this article was purchased by Li Juan with her own funds for a down payment, so the property should be owned by her.
3.However, it should be noted that after marriage, the two may have remodeled, renovated and other behaviors, which will also affect the appreciation of the property. According to the principle of division of property interests, Xiao Zhao can obtain part of the rights and interests of the value-added part.
4.According to article 44 of the Marriage Law, the wrongful acts of the spouses may have an impact on the division of property. In this story, the breakdown of the relationship between the two parties is caused by the mutual misalignment and conflict of the two parties, and there is no obvious situation where one party is at fault.
To sum up, in accordance with the provisions of the law, it is recommended that the court rule that Li Juan obtain the ownership of the property and negotiate to resolve the division of the value-added part. At the same time, it is also suggested that the two sides seek a possible reconciliation through reasonable dialogue and consultation. Because marital happiness is only possible if both parties are truly aware of the problem and work hard to solve it.