"Strong woman" Hu Sanniang met Li Shishi, proud or inferior? Reality Answers Revealed
First of all, it is important to emphasize that this is not a strange problem, but a very real one. In "Water Margin", Hu Sanniang and Li Shishi show two extreme and diametrically opposed characters: one is"Show up"The image of a strong woman, one is"Nothing will see the light of day"The image of the nobility. First of all, it should be noted that the two images have something in common, that is, they cannot be reconciled:
First: they are all beautiful and talented.
Second: no one can escape surveillance! Hu Sanniang couldn't escape Song Jiang's control, and Li Shishi couldn't escape Song Huizong's control.
When it comes to commonalities, we have to mention differences, and there is actually only one difference, and it is official. That is Hu Sanniang, who belongs to the heroes of Liangshan, at least officially, married to the bantam tiger Wang Ying to whom she belongs. And Master Li, although Song Huizong favored her, because of her identity, she couldn't marry in the palace, so her life didn't officially belong to her!
After talking about these two similarities and differences, let's go back to it"Water frontier"Period, with"Hu Sanniang met Master Li"to illustrate a very real problem.
i.When Hu Sanniang and Master Li meet, who will have the upper hand?
It is undoubtedly Master Li! Song Jiang also supported Li Shishi, that is, to divide gold and silver"Send"Liangshan beauty Yan Qing. In this way, of course, Master Li took advantage, so will Hu Sanniang regret it? The answer is no!
Hu Sanniang is a strong woman, Miss Qianjin was born, although she likes to dance with guns and sticks, but the education she received since she was a child is a very orthodox education, otherwise there would be no Song Jiang Zhujiazhuang, because her fiancé Zhujiazhuang is Zhutong.
Facts have proved that Li Ying has adopted a strategy of circumventing the wall among the three alliances. In fact, the Hu family can also adopt this strategy, but unfortunately Hu Sanniang can't pass this hurdle! This actually shows that Hu Sanniang has been taught to be orthodox since she was a child, and she can't marry or recognize her husband's family. It can be seen from this"Pig Li Shishi"At birth, Hu Sanniang's spirit was very depraved! With this in mind, let's turn to the second question below.
Secondly, will Hu Sanniang tell her husband Wang Ying about her meeting and relationship with Master Li?
Hu Sanniang's real lines in "Water Margin" only have two sentences, one of which is that Hu Sanniang grabbed Hu Yanzhuo's deputy general Peng Jie and shouted to Hua Rong:"General Hua, you rest, let me arrest this person! "The second is Hu Sanniang's questioning Qiong Ying (Zhang Qing's wife), this is the most critical sentence, let's look at the original book first:
When the short-haired tiger Wang Ying saw a beautiful woman, he suddenly took the lead in the battle, and flew Qiong Ying with a spear, and the two armies shouted, and Qiong Ying fought with a horse and a halberd. The two will fight for more than ten rounds, and Wang Short-haired Tiger Horse can't stop his heart, and the military law is in chaos. Qiong Ying thought to herself"This person is broken! "Seeing the crack, I saw a downwind ear piercing Wang Ying's left leg. Wang Ying's legs rose into the air, and Zhuo Buqun fell to the ground with a bang, knocking the horse to the ground. Hu Sanniang saw that her husband was injured and cried:"You thief and slut, how dare you be rude! "(Water Margin, Chapter 98).
Hu Sanniang stood up for her husband Wang Ying and reprimanded Qiong Ying, which once again confirmed that Hu Sanniang was a very traditional woman, albeit a strong woman. Unfortunately, Wang Ying's return this time is uncertain! This time, she was almost killed by Qiong Ying because she practiced openly on the battlefield"Tether the heart of a horse, tie the heart of a monkey"It didn't work out. On the other hand, as the saying goes, if a husband is a wife, Hu Sanniang must know why Qiong Ying defeated Wang Ying, so Hu Sanniang behaved like one"Tailor", sprinkled his anger on Qiong Ying.
Therefore, Master Li is a woman who can impress Song Huizong. If Hu Sanniang had seen Master Li, she would not have told her husband Wang Ying how Master Li treated Qiong Ying. This is because Hu Sanniang's entire pride in Master Li revolves"There is a place in life"(With a husband)! So, as long as she doesn't stop Hu Sanniang from saying"I'm in life", that's because Hu Sanniang has the spirit of despising Master Li! With these two points in mind, let's move on to the last question.
Third, are Hu Sanniang and Master Li happy?
Now it is certain that Hu Sanniang's life is indeed crooked and unhappy, but he is trying his best to maintain this form of happiness. What about Master Li? She was able to impress Song Huizong and become the most demure woman in Shuibo Liangshan, which is not only a matter of beauty, but also proves that Master Li has good kung fu. Master Li must have realized that this canary's wealth today has no basis, and even his life is in danger!
Because women such as Daji, Bao Xi, and Xiao Meiniang always bear the black pot for the fall of the dynasty, which is a historical convention. Master Li is proficient in law, chess, calligraphy and painting, and Bing Xue is smart, so he naturally understands the mystery here. And there have been since ancient times"Evacuation"The recent mysterious disappearance of Master Li is also possible. Therefore, Master Li's life is also tortuous and unhappy.
Knowing the actual situation of Hu Sanniang and Li Shishi in "Water Margin", a very real question will arise: what caused Hu Sanniang and Li Shishi"Precarious"Living situation? The reason has long been obvious: Hu Sanniang is controlled by Song Jiang, and Li Shishi is controlled by Song Huizong, and they have lost the freedom to do anything.
Who said that "Water Margin" is not female? Hu Sanniang, who is strong in martial arts, and Li Shishi, who is both talented and beautiful, are both extreme women, just like one who is trying to maintain it in the shadow of the sword"A sense of formal belonging"of strong women. One is to try to keep it in the shadow of the sword"A formal sense of belonging"The strong woman, one is eating"Youth rice", women who pretend to be elegant in a golden wire cage, but live a precarious life, are all peculiar and abnormal!
iv.Realistic results!
This is worth thinking about! Hu Sanniang's good impression of Li Shishi, whether it is pride or inferiority, does not depend on Hu Sanniang, nor does it depend on Li Shishi, but on the society's tolerance of women, that is, to give women the freedom they deserve! Although the women in "Water Margin" are a historical"Laggards"saved, but he created a more real problem!
This is actually another reminder to modern women, especially young women: to get rid of it"Hu Sanniang"、"Fourth Sister Li"There are two kinds of independence that must be achieved: personality independence and economic independence! Because these two kinds of independence are decisive factors in a free life with the right to choose!