Jimu News.
According to CCTV News, the "Measures for the Self-Discipline Management of Performers in the Performance Industry" stipulates that "entertainers shall not deceive the audience by means of fake singing and fake performances in commercial performances". The "Regulations on the Administration of For-profit Performances" also requires, "Actors shall not deceive the audience with fake singing, and the performance organizer shall not organize actors to fake sing." No unit or individual may provide conditions for lip-syncing. The unit holding the performance shall appoint special personnel to supervise the performance to prevent the occurrence of lip-syncing."
It is understood that "the tickets for this Shanghai concert are 355 to 1855 yuan, and the number of attendees for the 8 concerts exceeds 360,000.
On the morning of December 4th, "the whistleblower said that the live broadcast was confusing" ranked first in the hot search.
News
See more
On the afternoon of December 3, in an interview with a reporter from Jimu News, Chen Liang, director and founding partner of Hubei Good Law Firm, mentioned that because the purchase of concert tickets is a consumer behavior, "fake singing" violates the contract section of the Civil Code, the "Consumer Rights and Interests Protection" and other laws and regulations, and should bear the corresponding civil liability for compensation.
On February 5, 2021, the "Measures for the Self-Discipline Management of Performers in the Performance Industry" issued by the China Performance Industry Association stipulates that "entertainers shall not deceive the audience by means of fake singing and fake performances in commercial performances";On September 29, 2021, the Ministry of Culture and Tourism issued the "Notice on Regulating Performance Brokerage Behavior, Strengthening the Management of Actors, and Promoting the Healthy and Orderly Development of the Performance Market", which stipulates that "actors shall not be organized to sing falsetto, and conditions shall not be provided for falsetto singing";On September 12, 2023, the Ministry of Culture and Tourism and the Ministry of Public Security jointly issued the Notice on Further Strengthening the Standardized Management of Large-scale For-profit Performance Activities and Promoting the Healthy and Orderly Development of the Performance Market, which stipulates: "The cultural and tourism market management departments and comprehensive law enforcement agencies shall strengthen on-site inspections and ...... large-scale performance activitiesIllegal activities such as fake singing and fake performance are strictly prohibited. ”
The reporter saw in Article 47 of the "Regulations on the Administration of For-profit Performances" newly revised in November 2020 provided by Chen Liang that if there is "false-to-lip singing to deceive the audience" in a for-profit performance, "the audience has the right to request the performance organizer to compensate for losses in accordance with the relevant laws and regulations on the protection of consumer rights and interests after leaving."The performance organizer may recover compensation from the responsible theatrical performance groups and performers in accordance with law. ”
has not responded positively to the question of lip-syncingDare to act is the real "stubbornness".
Jimu News commentator Qu Jing
On December 3, the discussion of suspected lip-synching aroused the attention of netizens.
A netizen named "Farmer in the Wheat Field" identified the live sound source of the *** Shanghai concert on November 16 and found that nearly half of the 12 songs were lip-synching songs.
After that, the **brokerage company believes that the **staff hung up the reporter's ** after the reporter explained the intention of verification many times. The staff of the Shanghai Cultural Tourism Market Quality Inspection and Service Center responded that they would verify the problems reported by netizens, "Since the concert has ended, it will take some time to carry out an investigation." (According to the December 4 morning newspaper).
At 11 o'clock in the evening on December 3, the record company @believe** posted on Weibo that the performance of the Paris station on December 7, local time, will be broadcast live throughout the whole process, which seems to be a subtle way to respond to the question of lip-synching.
Netizens questioned the ** screenshot of "fake singing".
Believe the screenshot of the official Weibo.
This decision to broadcast the whole live broadcast is a "stubborn answer" in the eyes of fans, but in the eyes of ordinary viewers and netizens, it seems to be a response, but it is not fully responded, because even if the live broadcast of the Paris station is fully sung, it cannot be proved that there is no lip-synching in this concert in Shanghai. Therefore, although this answer is "stubborn", it is also quite vague.
Since the "lip-syncing" turmoil was exposed, the opinions of some fans and public netizens have been very different and far from each other. Most ordinary viewers believe that for such a well-known and popular band, lip-staging in a solo concert is a kind of disappointment to the audience's enthusiasmBut the opinions of fans are more complicated because of the mixture of fanatical love, past feelings, and differences in demand points.
Some fans firmly believe that *** does not lip-synch, thinking that *** itself is a powerful creative band, and the lead singer is not good at singing, there have been many "car accident scenes" over the years, and people who go to see *** concerts have never expected to hear perfect singing skills, so there is no need for "lip-synching" at all;
There are also some fans who think that even if *** really lip-synching, it is forgivable, the average age of the band is 45 years old, and this year there are many tours in many places across the country, and every atmosphere is hilarious**, it is normal for singers to feel powerless, in order to ensure a good performance effect, some songs lip-sync to save physical strength, as long as the fans don't care, as long as the scene is exciting to tears, what can't you do?
**Shanghai Concert Poster (*Weibo).
But it's really not that fans don't care, and if they don't care, they are all happy, and it should be.
First of all, the legal provisions are very clear, Article 28 of the "Regulations on the Administration of For-profit Performances" stipulates that actors shall not deceive the audience with fake singing, and the performance organizer shall not organize actors to sing falsetto. No unit or individual may provide conditions for lip-syncing. The unit holding the performance shall appoint special personnel to supervise the performance to prevent the occurrence of lip-syncing." So what if you lip-synch?The performance organizers, theatrical performance groups, and performers must be announced to the public by the competent department of culture and fined, and if they are announced again within 2 years, they will also have their for-profit performance permits or business licenses revoked. At the same time, the audience has the right to request the organizer to compensate for the losses in accordance with the relevant laws and regulations on the protection of consumer rights and interests after leaving the venue. It can be seen that if *** really lip-synched, at least he should apologize to the audience, accept the punishment of the competent department, and compensate the audience.
Moreover, the rights and interests of consumers cannot be violated, and the consumption in the field of entertainment, often because the main body of consumption is mostly fans, often presents a strange phenomenon of "buyers swear to protect sellers", obviously sometimes some consumption phenomena are not reasonable, there are various problems such as abnormally high and opaque information, but fans are not only willing to pay money, but also do not allow others to question their voices, which is obviously abnormal. Whether it is a fan or not, spending money to watch a concert is a consumer, and consumers ask to know whether the artist is lip-syncing, which is also a very legitimate act of rights protection, and there should be explanations, responses, and treatments.
Things have developed so far, I believe that it is not enough for the ** side to make such a specious response, whether there is lip-syncing or not is actually a matter of one sentence, there is no need to hide it. If there is no lip-synching, come up with a basis, and if you lip-sync, you will admit punishment and compensation in accordance with the law, and dare to act is really "stubborn", and only then can you be worthy of the audience's feelings and ticket money.
*: @新华社, CCTV News, Jimu News (Reporter: Fu Kan, Commentator: Qu Jing).
Editor: Liu Siyu and Huang Lin.
Review: Xie Likui.