Throughout history, there have been many people who were tortured by punishment, and their stories have been left to posterity and have become the subject of conversation. Among them, the most distressing and embarrassing is the oneMrs. QiFinish. She was a beautiful and kind woman, but she sufferedLv Pheasantwas deprived of his eyes, limbs and appearance, and lived in a pigsty filled with pig manure. Such a punishment is really cruel. However, in the treatmentMrs. QiThe question of whether the fate is worthy of sympathy, calendarHistorical RecordsZai and historical records provide different perspectives and interpretations. After in-depth understanding of the historical background of this story and the positions of all parties, perhaps we are interested inMrs. QiThere will be a different perception of what happened.
1. Ignoring Lu Pheasant's exploits
On the qualifications and ability to occupy power,Mrs. Qiand her sonLiu RuyiUnable to do withLv Pheasantand his son Liu Ying. Lv PheasantHave a long-term sittingGuanzhong, the merits of stabilizing the Han Dynasty, she once led the eradicationHan ShinwithPeng Yueand other actions of the rebels to makeHan DynastySettle down again. In contrast,Mrs. QiwithLiu Ruyi's talents and merits are relatively low, and they cannot meet the requirements of being an empress.
2. Disrespect for Liu Ying's status
Liu Ying asLiu BangThe son, who has long been in the position of the crown prince, has been consolidated in the hearts of the ministers. And compared to Liu Ying,Liu Ruyiis a character who has no outstanding talent and merit. Therefore,Mrs. QiForcing Liu Ying to be deposed in order to replace his son was an unscrupulous act.
3. Ignoring the stability and people's livelihood of the Han Dynasty
Mrs. Qionly considered the selfish interests of himself and his son, but did not consider the stability of the Han Dynasty and the peace and contentment of the people. Her actions are against the worldLi MinThe interests of the common people are just to satisfy their own and their son's ambitions. This kind of selfish behavior seriously hurt the foundation of the Han Dynasty and also led toLv PheasantTough measures against her.
1. Lv Pheasant's reasonable arrangement
Lv PheasantRightMrs. Qiand his son's disposition was not impulsive, but a series of reasonable arrangements. Liu Ying, as the crown prince, has been in charge for a long timeGuanzhong, ensuredLiu BangBase camp security when fighting outside. And eradicatedHan ShinwithPeng Yueand other rebels, tooLv PheasantHe made an important contribution to the stability of the Han Dynasty. In comparison,Mrs. QiwithLiu RuyiThe contribution is relatively small, and it cannot meet the needs of the status of the queen and the crown prince.
2, Mrs. Qi is not suitable to be a queen
fromMrs. QiJudging from her talent and morality, she is not suitable to be a queen. Except for singing and dancing, she has no other outstanding talents, nor has she made any important contributions to Dahan. In contrast,Lv PheasantNot only wisdom and ability, but also long-term sittingGuanzhong, it can be said that it is a more suitable candidate for the post of queen.
3. Lu Pheasant provided many opportunities
Lv Pheasantin the treatMrs. QiwithLiu RuyiIn the process, they have been given the opportunity. Liu BangOnce givingMrs. Qileft three ways to live, let her be a man with her tail between her legs, away from Chang'an, or by the important ministersZhou ChangProtect them. IfMrs. QiTook the advice and wentZhao Guorefuge, or byZhou Changprotection, their mother and child will not sufferLv PheasantCruelty.
To sum up, for:Mrs. QiWe can draw different perspectives from different perspectives. If we only know this story from film and television dramas and **, we will be more sympatheticMrs. Qi, think she's a poor victim. However, knowing this story from historical records, we may be rightMrs. QiThere are different opinions. Her unscrupulous and selfish behavior led to her defeat in the political struggle of the time. Although she was subjected to cruel treatment, it was also the result of her deserved sin. So we're interested in:Mrs. QiWhether or not the plight of the case merits sympathy should be considered on the basis of historical facts and the views of all parties.