The night was low, the stars were twinkling, and there was a faint sense of melancholy in the quiet community. Fu Jiahui sat alone on the balcony, staring at the stars outside the window, but there was a turbulent wave in her heart. Her marriage once collapsed, and with the company of her daughter, Xiaoxiao, she regained hope in life. However, fate played tricks on her again, and Tong Xiao's departure made her feel the ruthlessness of fate. Now, her daughter has left her, and she is left alone, facing the rest of her life alone.
On this silent night, the only thing that breaks the loneliness is the knock on the door. Fu Jiahui was slightly comforted in her heart, knowing that this was her son-in-law Lu Bin who came to see her. Lu Bin was carrying two packages, one large and one small, and when he saw Fu Jiahui, a smile of relief appeared on his face. Fu Jiahui looked at him, and a trace of gratitude welled up in her heart. After all, her daughter had only left for a short time, and Lu Bin was able to stay by her side so firmly, which made her feel the warmth of family affection.
Lu Bin looked at Fu Jiahui's tear-wet eyes, and said gently: "Mom, I'm not here to eat, I want to discuss something with you." His words were a little slurred, and seemed a little difficult to speak. Fu Jiahui was a little confused by his words, and she didn't know what her son-in-law had to discuss with her. Her heart was full of questions, waiting for Lu Bin to continue.
Lu Bin cleared his throat and continued to speak: "Mom, you see that Tong Xiao is gone, I am ready to sell that house, do you see if you give it to me at a discount, or do I sell it and we divide it equally?"Fu Jiahui was dumbfounded, she suspected that she had misheard, could it be that her daughter had just died, and Lu Bin actually brought up the topic of houses. What made her even more angry was that she bought this house for 410,000 yuan before her daughter's diagnosis, and it was registered in her daughter's name to protect her daughter's life. This is obviously his daughter's pre-marital property, but now Lu Bin actually wants a piece of the pie, and he can't say anything about it.
Fu Jiahui was so angry that the water glass in her hand began to tremble, and a touch of disbelief crossed her eyes. Seeing that she was silent, Lu Bin continued: "Mom, since Tong Xiao didn't leave a will, I asked the lawyer, both of us are legal heirs in this suite, one and a half. If you are reluctant to sell, give me half of the market price, and if you agree to sell, I will go to the intermediary now. Lu Bin's words were full of confidence, it seemed that he was prepared and had already made all the plans.
Fu Jiahui was furious and responded word by word: "Since you have asked the lawyer, have you ever asked about the "Prenuptial Property Agreement" signed by you and Xiaoxiao?It is clearly written that after Xiaoxiao's death, this house belongs to me, does it have legal effect?She took out the agreement left by her daughter from the drawer and slapped it on the table, and Lu Bin immediately panicked. He remembered that Tong Xiao was worried about his mother's pension after his death, so he negotiated and signed this agreement with Lu Bin. At that time, Lu Bin had a heart to belong to, and signed the agreement head-on, but he didn't expect it to fall into the hands of Fu Jiahui.
Lu Bin, I thank you for giving my daughter marriage and accompanying her on her last journey, but I said at the time, I don't want to drag you down, you insist on marrying, you are an adult, this is your own choice. The house I bought for 410,000 yuan and gave it to Xiaoxiao, which belongs to her pre-marital property, and you have no right to divide it. Fu Jiahui's voice pierced Lu Bin's heart like frost, and he realized that he had made a wrong decision. So, Lu Bin hurriedly started a lawsuit and wanted to divide the property through legal means.
Aunt Fan's point of view:
1.Her son-in-law, Lu Bin, was by her side before she left, which brought her comfort and touch. He decided to hold a wedding with his daughter, which made her feel the beauty of love and reduced the regrets in her life.
2.After the death of his daughter, his son-in-law Lu Bin still cared about his mother and asked if he would sell the house and share the money equally. This shows that he also cares about Fu Jiahui's life and financial situation, and hopes to be able to provide her with support and help.
Uncle Wang's point of view:
1.Son-in-law Lu Bin brought comfort and emotion to her daughter before she left, but now he values her daughter's house, showing that his motives in marriage are not pure. He wants a piece of the pie, which is disrespectful and unfair to his daughter.
2.The house that Fu Jiahui bought and gave to her daughter with full money is her daughter's pre-marital property, and Lu Bin has no right to claim to divide or sell it. His actions are against morality and law, and after his daughter's death, he should respect his daughter's wishes and Fu Jiahui's rights and interests.
After a detailed study of the agreement and relevant legal terms, the lawyer gave the following legal opinion:
1.While her daughter was still alive, Fu Jiahui had the legal right to buy a house and donated the property to her daughter, and the property in her daughter's name belonged to her private property.
2.The "Prenuptial Property Agreement" signed by Fu Jiahui and Tong Xiao is a valid agreement, which clearly stipulates that the property will be owned by Fu Jiahui after Tong Xiao's death and will have legal effect.
3.Even if Tong Xiao did not leave a will, Lu Bin, as Tong Xiao's husband, could only inherit Tong Xiao's other properties, but could not divide the property in Fu Jiahui's name.
4.Therefore, according to the existing legal provisions and agreements, Lu Bin could not legally request the division of the property.
Lu Bin had to give up his claim for the division of the property under the legal advice of his lawyer. He finally realized his mistake and felt his meanness. He left Fu Jiahui's house without shame, sad.
In this early morning story, a legal battle ends the property dispute. Fu Jiahui is grateful to her daughter for leaving the agreement, so that her rights and interests have been protected. However, the pain in her heart could not be easily healed. She lost her daughter, the passionate and hopeful woman she had in her youth. She was left alone, alone for the rest of her life.