Preamble:
Russia's surprise attack forced Ukrainian forces to retreat, while Kyiv was in a panic. And now, Ukrainian officials are deliberately sending prisoners to the front line to compensate for the lack of troops. This resolution has caused controversy and questioning. Whether the prisoner can complete the combat mission has become a topic of discussion.
Kyiv panics: Ukrainian troops retreat, prisoners are undergoing domestic operations.
The Ukrainian army was crushed by the ** people, the key Avadiivka fell into the hands of Russia, and the people of Kyiv were panicked. Although the Ukrainian side tried to explain its withdrawal, defeat was a foregone conclusion, and all excuses became meaningless. In the current situation of the lack of strength of the Ukrainian army, official Kyiv has proposed to throw the prisoners into battle. Ukraine's Minister of Justice, Denis Malyuska, said that about 50,000 Ukrainian men were not drafted into the army and that they should be considered future servicemen. He believed that not every criminal would shoot at his comrades, so some criminals were quite powerful. He also proposed, in the absence of confidence in the criminals, to distribute shovels to them and let them go to battle with them. For some unknown reason, these prisoners have not yet been mobilized. Perhaps it won't be long before Alexei Goncharenko, a member of the Ukrainian parliament, has confirmed that he has developed a bill aimed at strengthening the Russian army, and at the same time, Zelensky's alternate appointments with Syrsky will be fully implemented. Zelensky has made it clear that taking turns means that when the soldiers are tired, they can leave the line and be replaced by the next soldier. This sentence is easy to say, but it is very difficult to do, the first task of Ukraine is to mobilize the army, and if there is not enough strength, no one will propose to send prisoners to the front. The Russians also fought with shovels, and although they were ridiculed, they used shovels to cut through the wide defensive circle. In this case, the Ukrainians will not necessarily be discouraged by this and are willing to fight with a shovel, so let them be. The mobilization of criminals is an issue worth pondering. Ordinary Ukrainians ran out, and the prisoners joined the fighting, but they were in a dangerous situation, no one knew, no one knew.
Additional note: This resolution has aroused heated discussions in the whole society. Some believe that the throwing of prisoners into the battlefield is a necessity of the situation in Ukraine, because in wartime, the shortage of troops is inevitable. But there are also those who are skeptical about the loyalty and combat skills of the criminals. In this smoky war, it becomes a question of whether to involve criminals. The people of Ukraine also have different opinions on this, some of which bring danger to criminals, and some bring unpredictable dangers to the war; Others argue that every force should play a role, including criminals, in times of national crisis.
Dilemma: Difficulty in mobilizing prisoners.
With the retreat of Ukrainian troops and the crisis in Kiev, the transfer of prisoners of war is an urgent move. Although this move has alleviated the situation of the "shortage of soldiers" of the Ukrainian army to a certain extent, there are also many problems and problems. The quality and loyalty of criminals are in doubt, and their ability to take on the heavy responsibility of defending their families and countries in war has become a dilemma for policymakers. Denis Malyuska's suggestion to let the captives go into battle with shovels was crude, but it was also controversial. They fear that the lack of formal military training and adaptation of these prisoners will lead to all sorts of unintended consequences, as well as more chaos and death. Therefore, the decision to transfer prisoners is a big problem, both morally and practically.
Additional note: The legal and ethical issues relating to the transfer of prisoners have also been widely debated. Some legal experts have expressed the compatibility of prisoners' participation in war with international conventions and human rights norms, and whether they should be compelled to participate in war, even if their lives are in danger. On the other hand, the situation of the prisoners themselves also makes people think about whether they need to risk their lives to die despite their guilt, which is a matter of humanity and justice. In making this decision, Ukraine** should carefully weigh the stakes in order to ensure that the rights and dignity of detainees are respected while ensuring the security of the country.
Reflection summary. At a time when Ukraine is facing an unprecedented nationwide crisis, the decision to throw prisoners into the war is highly controversial. There are voices of support and opposition on all sides for the involvement of prisoners in this battle, and there are different opinions. Regarding the transfer of prisoners, I think it should be viewed from various angles, not with a "shovel". To maintain the security of a nation, it is also necessary to give due respect to the dignity of every human being, even criminals. The participation of criminals in the war is a tortuous road, and it requires the full cooperation of the legal profession and the whole society to find a more reasonable and humane way. We are confident that we will find the best solution for the nation and humanity in this chaotic period in Ukraine.