Recently, a case involving extramarital grants has attracted a lot of attention. After discovering the improper money exchange between her husband Ma and Wang, Shi decided to take action to protect her rights and interests. The strange woman was arrogant: This is the money I gave to my brother, why should I have your consent? I don't pay it back! Case review
On a quiet summer night in 2021, the breeze gently blew the curtains, and Shi sat on the sofa at home, feeling uneasy in his heart. On the screen of her husband Ma's mobile phone, the WeChat prompt sound kept ringing, like a secret call, luring her to explore the truth. (All names in the article are pseudonyms) Ma usually protects his mobile phone tightly and never lets her touch it easily. But tonight, he forgot to take his phone with him when he took a shower, which gave Shi a rare opportunity. She hesitated, but curiosity eventually drove her to pick up her phone, unlock the screen, and slide open the WeChat interface. The chat record was like an open Pandora's box, and a strong sense of betrayal surged into Shi's heart. Her conversation with the woman surnamed Wang is full of ambiguity, and the words reveal an unusual intimacy. What's even more shocking is that the transfer records show that Ma has successively transferred more than 5 million yuan to the woman surnamed Wang. 
Shi felt like a knife, she couldn't imagine that her husband had such a deep financial relationship with another woman behind his back. This amount of money is almost a huge amount of money for their ordinary family. Feeling angry, betrayed and desperate, she decided to get the money back and defend her family and rights. She found the address of the woman surnamed Wang and knocked on her door with mixed feelings. When the door opened, a woman with elaborate makeup and fashionable clothes appeared in front of her. In the face of Shi's questioning, the woman surnamed Wang did not feel a trace of guilt, but said in a provocative tone: "What if you are husband and wife? Ma and I are just brother and sister, he gave me money, but he didn't say he wanted to inform you. Shi was trembling with anger at these words, but she tried to stay calm. She knew that anger would not solve the problem, and she had to take action to defend her rights. So, she decided to seek legal help and have a professional do justice for her. Legal AnalysisIn terms of law, the focus of the dispute in this case is whether Wang must return the more than 500 funds transferred to his account by Ma. According to Article 153 of the Civil Code, civil juristic acts that are contrary to public order and good customs are invalid. Ma donated a large amount of money to Wang without the consent of Shi, the co-owner of the property, which was not necessary for daily life, but also seriously damaged Shi's lawful rights and interests. Therefore, the gift should be found to be invalid, and the donee Wang should return it. 
In addition, article 157 of the Civil Code stipulates that after a civil juristic act is invalid, the property acquired by the actor as a result of the act shall be returned. Therefore, Wang should return the money to Shi. In addition, on the premise that the two defendants have families and spouses, it is obviously contrary to the principle of public order and good customs to express love to the opposite sex outside of marriage with figures of special significance. This kind of behavior not only destroys the trust between husband and wife, but also violates the basic moral requirements of society for marriage and family. In the end, the court ruled that their gift was invalid, and Wang should return 3210650 yuan of the joint property of Shi and his wife. Case Reflection In married life, the relationship between money and emotions must be handled properly. Money can buy many things, but it can't buy true love and trust. If you want to measure feelings in terms of money, then eventually you may find that you have lost not only money, but also more precious things - such as family, such as love. True feelings need to be managed and maintained with heart, not measured by money. Remember the saying: "Love is not a transaction, but a priceless commitment." "[Disclaimer] This article is adapted from a true story, the case process of the article, **all** on the Internet, this article aims to popularize the law with cases, no vulgarity and other bad guidance. If it involves copyright or character infringement issues, please contact us in time, and we will delete the content!