In this case, the defendant Feng Moumou was accused of knowing that others had opened a leisure store to control women, but still visited the women for medical treatment and injections without a license on many occasions, and provided assistance in organizing ** activities. The court of first instance and the court of second instance both found that Feng's conduct constituted the crime of assisting in organizing **.
The crime of assisting in organizing ** refers to the crime of recruiting or transporting people for the person of the organization, or having other acts of assisting in organizing others. In the judgment of the case, Feng's behavior was found to be "other acts of assisting in organizing others". Although he was not directly involved in the recruitment or transportation of personnel, his medical services provided important support and facilitation for the organization of the event, which made it possible for the event to run more smoothly.
The duties of a doctor and the boundaries of the law
In this case, there are some debatable points in the verdict's conviction of the defendant Feng.
First of all, Feng's actions were essentially for medical purposes, and his duty was to provide medical services to patients. His behavior of visiting the first woman to see a doctor and give injections is based on his professional ethics and concern for the health of patients. Such an act in itself does not directly equate to assisting the organization**.
Secondly, Feng Moumou may not be aware of the control of women** in leisure stores. His focus is on the health of his patients and he may not be aware of the activities of a leisure store. Therefore, whether his actions have the intention of subjectively and intentionally assisting the organization** needs to be further examined and considered.
In addition, the application of the law should weigh various factors. In this case, the professional responsibility and ethical code of the doctor should be given some consideration. A doctor's primary duty is to treat a patient, not to judge a patient's profession or background. Characterizing a doctor's normal medical conduct as a crime could have an unnecessarily chilling effect on the medical profession and cause doctors to be apprehensive in the performance of their duties. Of course, if Feng is not qualified to engage in medical treatment, he should be convicted and sentenced for the crime of illegal medical practice.
Feng Moumou's behavior does have a certain relationship with the organization's activities, and for similar situations, relevant laws and regulations should be more clear and detailed to define the boundaries of doctors' behaviors in similar situations. At the same time, it is also necessary to strengthen the supervision and education of the medical industry, improve doctors' awareness of potential legal risks, and avoid inadvertently involving illegal acts.