In the past two years, when Wu Dalang is mentioned, it is guaranteed that some people will say: Wu Dalang's prototype Wu Zhi, tall and handsome, was a jinshi in the Yongle period, and had been the county magistrate of Yanggu County;His wife Pan is a famous lady, gentle and virtuous, and Wu Zhi respects each other like guests.
Shi Nai'an and Wu Zhi have a grudge, so they scandalize Wu Zhi's husband and wife in the book.
However, history records that Shi Nai'an died in Hongwu three years.
How did the person who died in the third year of Hongwu get into a feud with the county order decades later?Could it be that Shi Nai'an is a traverser?
In addition, whether Wu Zhiqi exists or not is still being investigated.
In the Ming Dynasty's "Qinghe County Chronicles", there is no record of Wu Zhi and Pan Jinlian. It's just that there are more folk legends, so in the newly revised "Qinghe County Chronicles", in the form of folk literature, Wu Zhi and Pan Jinlian are included.
More importantly, historical records record that in the Hongwu and Yongle dynasties, there was no Jinshi named Wuzhi at all.
Therefore, Wu Dalang and Pan Jinlian are completely fictional characters. Shi Nai'an's black martial arts is a complete rumor.
There have always been rumors that Pan Jinlian is a chaste martyr, otherwise how could she refuse the entanglement of a big family?
She and Ximen Qing were irrational behaviors that gave up on themselves after being rejected by their true love Wu Song.
But in the original book, Pan Jinlian is an inappropriate adulteress. She refuses to be entangled by big households, not because of how chaste and self-loving she is, but because she is old and ugly, she can't look down on them.
In the original book, Pan Jinlian's nature is very clear, and her biggest hobby is to study how to eat rock candy with her children.
It has always been rumored among the people that Wu Song's martial arts are not as good as Ximen Qing.
There are many theories about the reason why Wu Song was able to kill Ximenqing. It is said that Wu Song's skin is rough and thick, and Ximen Qing was ground to death;It is said that Wu Dalang appeared and frightened Ximen Qing, and Wu Song took the opportunity to kill him;It is said that when Wu Song went to the capital, he met Zhou Tong and learned two tricks and was able to defeat Ximen Qing......
In short, Wu Song's martial arts are not good, and it was a complete accident that he was able to kill Ximenqing.
Although these rumors are interesting, they make Wu Song's killing of Ximenqing more exciting than the original work.
But rumors are rumors after all, and in the original book, Wu Song only used one trick to beat Ximenqing.
At that time, Ximenqing punched Wu Song's heart, Wu Song easily dodged, grabbed Ximenqing, and threw it down from the upper floor, Ximenqing was seriously injured and dying. It's that simple and straightforward.
In the 98 version of "Water Margin", Wu Song and Sun Erniang were very ambiguous, and Sun Erniang even died to save Wu Song.
may be affected by this, there have been rumors, Wu Song and Sun Erniang are not clear.
But in the original work, it was Zhang Qing who was really good to Wu Song, and Wu Song and Sun Erniang didn't say a few words in total.
Sun Erniang finally died under Du Wei's flying knife, instead of saving Wu Song.
Because everyone doesn't like the plot of Zhao'an, plus Chao Gai and Ruan's three heroes in 98 "Water Margin" oppose Zhao'an.
Therefore, there were rumors that Chao Gai and his family opposed Zhao'an.
But in the original book, when Chao Gai was alive, Liang Shan already had the intention of recruiting An. The first to put "loyalty" on his lips was also Chao Gai.
Ruan's three heroes did not oppose Zhao'an, and Ruan Xiaoqi even comforted Song Jiang after Ruan Xiaosui's death, "My brother sacrificed his life for national affairs today, and it is as if he died in Liangshanbo and buried his name." ”
Gongsun Sheng did not oppose Zhao'an, because Zhao'an was arranged by the Nine Heavens Xuannu. Gongsun Sheng, a cultivator, how could he oppose the arrangement of the big guy above?
Some people may ask, you said that Ruan Xiaoqi didn't recruit An, so why did he secretly change the imperial wine when he recruited An for the first time?
Ruan Xiaoqi really didn't fight against Zhao'an, he did it for the first time.
When the imperial court recruited an for the first time, ** regarded the heroes of Liangshan as grass mustard, and did not take the heroes of Liangshan in their eyes at all, and their words and deeds were full of contempt.
How can Ruan Xiaoqi's temper be endured?Naturally, we have to take care of the dog officials who look down on people.
In "Water Margin", the real opposition to Zhao'an is Cai Jing, Gao Yu, Tong Guan and other traitorous ministers.
Fang La in the original book is not a hero with strong martial arts, but a villain who abuses and kills the people and has ordinary martial arts.
The ending was that he was knocked down by Lu Zhishen with a Zen staff and easily captured alive.
As for Wu Song's broken arm and capturing Fang La, that is the plot of folklore and Yuan miscellaneous dramas, not "Water Margin".
There have always been rumors that Lu Junyi, Shi Wengong, and Lin Chong are Zhou Tong's apprentices;Wu Song's trick "Jade Ring Step, Mandarin Duck Foot" was passed down by Zhou Tong.
But in the original work of "Water Margin", there is no such person as Zhou Tong, and Lu Junyi and Lin Chong are not brothers.
Lu Junyi and Lin Chong are Zhou Dong**, from the Qing Dynasty Qian Cai's "Saying Yue Quanbiography".
As for the statement that Wu Song and Shi Wengong studied under Zhou Tong, it comes from folklore and the interpretation and adaptation of storytelling artists.
Jin Sheng, a great genius in the late Ming and early Qing dynasties, was a Song Jianghei. For the sake of Black Song Jiang, he did everything he could, and even modified the original work.
The conspiracy theory that Song Jiang killed Chao Gai is a rumor made up by Jin Shengsi.
In the original book, after Chao Gai's death, his ghost appeared twice. Once prompted Song Jiang to find An Daoquan for treatment;once entangled Shi Wengong, allowing Lu Junyi to capture him alive.
If Chao Gai was really killed by Song Jiang, then why did Chao Gai's yin soul want to save Song Jiang and entangle Shi Wengong?Is he a fool?
Therefore, Chao Gai really died under Shi Wengong's arrow.
Now when it comes to the heroes of Liangshan, there is definitely a lot of scolding. For no other reason, the heroes did do a lot of evil things.
Even Lu Zhishen has a black history of drinking**, smashing temples, and forcing monks to eat meat.
But to deny everything about the heroes is biased.
After all, there are two sides to human beings, and they can change their ways.
According to the original book, after Song Jiang grasped the power of Liangshan, he strictly restrained the heroes, and did not commit any crimes in the autumn where he passed.
After capturing the city, kill the bullies, open a warehouse and release grain, and relieve the poor people.
He also successively destroyed Tian Hu, Wang Qing, and Fang La, the three villains who tortured and killed the people.
Therefore, even cannibals like Sun Erniang, Li Li, and Yan Shun have done good things.
Otherwise, how could there be a prevalent singing and dancing in the Chaoshan generation?
Is it true that the ancient people did not know what was wrong and commemorated a group of villains who would only do evil?