Recently, the Baoshan Court in Shanghai heard a case in which a daughter wanted to study abroad and requested to divide the house shared with her parents in order to obtain a discount.
Xiao Tian, only 25 years old, is the only daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Tian. After her grandfather and grandmother moved to the old house, they got a house in Baoshan District. When Oda was 16 years old, the property rights to the house became jointly owned by Mr. and Mrs. Tian and Oda and the three of them. Since the death of my grandfather, this apartment has been lived by my grandmother alone.
However, in 2021, Oda had conflicts with his parents over issues such as studying abroad and choosing a job, and began to live in a rented house. She wanted to divide the house she shared, but her parents refused. In July of the same year, Xiao Tian, Mr. and Mrs. Tian and his grandmother signed an agreement, stipulating that after the death of his grandmother, the house would be transferred**, and Xiao Tian would get the corresponding payment.
Oda said that studying abroad has been her dream for many years, but her parents refused to provide financial help. She had offered to buy her share of the house in common or at her parents' expense, but her parents firmly refused. Therefore, on the grounds that Xiao Tian urgently needed funds to study and live, he sued Mr. and his wife to the Baoshan District People's Court, requesting that the house be divided. She wants the house to be ruled that Mr. and Mrs. Tian are to be given a discount of one third of the value of the house.
During the trial, the defendants, Mr. Tian and his wife, argued that the house in question belonged to the three of them. Since they acquired the title to the house, there has been no change in family relations, no loss of common grounds, and no significant reason for the need for partition. Moreover, they have been helping Xiao Tian repay various loans and pay various expenses, totaling more than 50 yuan. They also actively contacted the study abroad school for Oda, but they were rejected due to problems such as unsatisfactory school rankings. At present, the husband and wife are also unable to pay the discount price after acquiring the house, so they do not agree to Oda's claim.
After trial, the Baoshan District People's Court held that, according to Article 303 of the Civil Code, there is no agreement or statutory circumstance for the division of the house in this case. First of all, the registration of the rights of the plaintiff defendant after acquiring the house in this case was joint ownership, and the family identity of the three people had not changed, so this case did not meet the circumstances of loss of the basis of co-ownership. Second, there was no sufficient evidence to subscribe to Oda's request for the division of the house on the grounds of studying abroad and living, and even if the reason objectively existed, it was not a material reason for the division of the common property. In the end, the grandmother of the original owner of the house still actually lived in it, and the plaintiff and the defendant agreed to wait until the grandmother was "100 years old" before involving the issue of housing **. At present, both parties have expressed their inability to pay the other party's discount, so it is not appropriate to divide the house in this case at present.
In summary, the Baoshan District People's Court rejected all of the plaintiff Xiaotian's claims. After the first-instance verdict, Oda appealed, and the second-instance verdict was upheld.
For this matter, netizens quarreled.
Some netizens said that this number has been abolished, so hurry up and re-practice a trumpet.
But some netizens disagreed, saying that according to their situation, the server should have banned them from registering a new account, and there was no way to retrain.
Some netizens said that it really doesn't work, it's okay to get a second-hand number, and now that the password has been leaked, practicing again is pure money.
Some netizens retorted that there is a problem with the number practice method, and no matter how many numbers you practice, it will be in vain. Playing a game doesn't just mean that you can just top up, you also have to master the skills. Oda's parents are not suitable for playing this game, so let's quit the game.
The woman sued her parents for not paying for her to study abroad