In court, Xu Wenhui cried again and again.
* The whole body, the mouth is stuffed with cotton cloth, the cigarette butt is hot, and the last slap kills, claiming that the beating and scolding is for education"When just nudged her lightly"**Arms, wires, cigarette butts hot palms, punishment ...... kneelingJust finished two months of left-behind life, a four-year-old girl Qianru because"Disobedient"was tortured and killed by his father Xu Wenhui in a rented house in Dongguan, and the incident caused an uproar in the society after it was reported by ** (reported by the Guangdong edition of the newspaper on April 6). The reporter learned on August 1 that the First People's Court of Dongguan City dealt with Xu Wenhui on July 24"Father kills daughter"The verdict was pronounced in the case, and the defendant Xu Wenhui was sentenced to 10 years in prison and deprived of political rights for one year for the crime of intentional injury. It is understood that the verdict in this case was not **, and the case has not yet passed the appeal period, and Xu Wenhui intends to appeal.
In June 2011, Xu Wenhui and his wife Hu Hongmei discussed, and took their daughter Xiao Qianru, who was far away from her hometown in Sichuan, to Dongguan, and prepared to enroll her in a local kindergarten. Xiao Qianru, who came to Dongguan happily, thought that she would never have to be separated from her parents again, but she didn't expect that Xiao Qianru's 4-year-old life came to an abrupt end after 2 months, and it was her father who brought her back to the abyss of death with his own hands.
According to Xu Wenhui's neighbors, Xiao Qianru had just arrived in Dongguan for the first week, and the couple treated her very well, taking their daughter out shopping after work. But the good times didn't last long, a week later, Xu Wenhui often beat and scolded Xiao Qianru, and Xiao Qianru's wailing and crying were often heard in the staff dormitory.
Xu Wenhui, who advocates stick education, has used many methods"Education"'s daughter, not only wrapped the wire with tape and hit Xiaoru's butt and thighs, but also burned Xiao Qianru's palm with a cigarette butt. In order to stop her from rummaging through the house, Xu Wenhui even tied her to the toilet and balcony with a belt until the couple got off work. Basically, every other day, Xiao Qianru will be because of"Disobedient"And beaten.
The dust cloth plugged his mouth, and he almost choked his breath, and his father slapped the woman to kill her.
At about 12 o'clock on August 15 last year, Xiao Qianru's mother Hu Hongmei returned to the rental house from work and found that her daughter had stirred a variety of seasonings placed on the balcony kitchenware and ate them. Hu Hongmei wrapped a piece of tape around her daughter's palm and told her husband, who came home later, about it. Xu Wenhui was very angry after hearing this, and took his daughter's hands ** and burned his daughter's palms with cigarette butts. Xiao Qianru was so hot that she cried and shouted for help.
Xu Wenhui not only did not stop, but also casually plugged his daughter's mouth with dust cloth and paper. It wasn't until Xiao Qianru, who was gagged, had difficulty breathing, that Xu Wenhui took out the dust cloth in her mouth. Xiao Qianru then fell to the ground and vomited. Seeing this, Xu Wenhui immediately burst into flames and ordered her to clean up the ground. When Xiao Qianru picked up the vomit and walked to the bathroom, Xu hit her in the face with his hand, and Xiao Qianru's head fell to the ground, and she fell unconscious after that, and was sent to the hospital for emergency treatment and died. According to the forensic examination, Xiao Qianru died of head injury caused by blunt external force. Subsequently, Xu Wenhui went to the local police station to stamp the death certificate. The police thought that the cause of Xiao Qianru's death was strange, and found that Xiao Qianru had multiple bruises all over her body during the inspection. **So an investigation was launched, and all kinds of evidence showed that Xu Wenhui was suspected of intentionally harming his daughter. He was then arrested by the police.
Daddy Wolf"Hi stick education, claiming to have unintentionally killed children.
On April 5, 2011, Xu Wenhui was tried in the Dongguan No. 1 People's Court on suspicion of intentional injury. During the trial, Xu Wenhui insisted that the beating and scolding of Xiao Qianru was to educate her, not to abuse her, and should not constitute the crime of intentional injury. Xu Wenhui said with tears in his eyes"Both my husband and I work, but I don't want my daughter to become a left-behind child, so even if life is difficult, I still bring her back from my hometown to raise her. ”
As a security captain, Xu Wenhui used to be a soldier, and in his heart he had long believed that only stick education could get rid of Xiao Qianru's bad habits. In court, Xu Wenhui said:"The four brothers in my family were all beaten and scolded by their mothers since childhood, and many of the other partners around me have committed crimes and gone to prison. I worked to support my family, and before the accident, I always thought that stick education was no problem. "He was given a light sentence and sent to the hospital for emergency treatment, where he was sentenced to a minimum sentence.
During the trial, Xu Wenhui's defense lawyer made two defense opinions for him, arguing that Xu actively sent his daughter to the hospital and had voluntarily surrenderedMoreover, as a daughter, Xu Wenhui's behavior was different from other intentional injury cases, which were rejected by the court.
As for the circumstances of voluntary surrender, the court held that after Xu Wenhui's daughter died, he went to the police station to request a cremation certificate, but did not truthfully report the cause of his daughter's death to the public security police, which was a passive return to the case and could not be found to be voluntary surrender. The court did not accept the defense lawyer's argument that Xu Wenhui and his wife were too busy to take care of their daughter, which led to the occurrence of this case. At the same time, the court held that Xu Wenhui and his wife sent their daughter to the hospital for emergency treatment in time after the incident, and Xu Wenhui could be given a lighter punishment.
The court found Xu Wenhui guilty of intentional injury and sentenced him to 10 years in prison. According to the law, intentional injury causing death is punishable by more than 10 years, which means that Xu Wenhui was sentenced to a minimum sentence.
Lawyer objected to"Abuse crimes"It seems that it would be more appropriate to deal with it.
In an interview with a reporter from Yangcheng Evening News on August 1, Zhang Qingsong, one of the top ten criminal defense lawyers in the country, a member of the Criminal Professional Committee of the All China Lawyers Association, and director of the Beijing Shangquan Law Firm, said that the court did not adopt the opinions of the defendant's defense lawyer"Quite right", but the charges were found to be"Intentional injury"Inappropriate.
Zhang Qingsong said:"Personally, I don't think this charge is appropriate if it were to be covered by Article 260 of the Penal Code, "Abuse Crime".'Abuse of a family member'is more appropriate. "The subject matter of the case is consistent with the offence ("Father and daughter, mother and daughter"family relations), which are also met at the level of objective requirements"Long-term, recurrent characteristics"。
This child is constantly beaten, ** restricted freedom, which is more in line with'Abuse crimes'Because his father was not simply suddenly and deliberately beaten to death. "Zhang Qingsong explained that the crime of intentional injury is generally a one-time physical assault on the victim. Zhang Qingsong said that if convicted of abuse, the defendant would be sentenced to up to seven years in prison.