The remake of the four famous novels is a thankless task, especially with classics like the CCTV version in the way.
But this is also a theme that can attract the most audiences and investment, the new version of "Water Margin" was released in 2011, and the length of 86 episodes still restores most of the content.
At this point, the new version is better than the CCTV version, and there are a lot of heroes and storylines that have been refilmed, but there are also some problems.
In the old version of "Water Margin", Pan Jinlian played by actor Wang Siyi looks very moving, but it is not yet to the point of being a great beauty.
She gives people the impression that she is quite a beautiful woman, and she has a very close feeling.
And Pan Jinlian in the new version is too exquisite, like the top brand in the green building, living a life of fine clothes and food, and is sought after by thousands of people.
Referring to her like a green onion** like a lady of Wu Dalang who lives a hard life?
The first impression of the two actors is very different.
In order to play this role well, Wang Siyi spent a lot of effort, and even really learned to make cooking cakes.
When the two of them knocked down the bamboo pole, Wang Siyi looked like a beautiful little lady, and Gan Tingting looked like a rich lady in the depths of the boudoir.
The difference in the temperament of the actors often affects the audience's first feeling.
However, Pan Jinlian in the old version was portrayed as a woman with extenuating circumstances and an unhappy marriage.
All her behaviors were completed under the pressure of Wang Po and Ximenqing step by step, and there was an intuitive feeling of forcing her to become a prostitute.
This is far from the original **.
In the old version of "Water Margin", Wu Song and Ximenqing's "Lion Tower Battle" is a major event.
Wudutou was full of firepower, and Ximenqing was beaten indiscriminately, and this scene in the original book was easily brought over, because although Ximenqing had some fists and feet, in front of the tiger hero Wu Song, it was just a primary school student.
In order to increase the ornamentality, the old version set the force value of the two toThree-seven open, Ximenqing has the strength to fight back, but it is just to make him more resistant to beating.
In the new version, the director directly raised Ximenqing's force value above Wu Song.
If it weren't for the usual spending time drinking and not taking care of his waist, it is estimated that this version of Ximen Qing would be able to fight against the Jade Qilin Lu Junyi.
I really don't understand why the director wants Ximenqing to be so strong, Wu Song was almost put to the ground by Ximenqing.
If it weren't for the aura of the protagonist, Wu Song would probably be offline.
And Wu Song, played by Chen Long, doesn't talk about whether he is burly or not, just this look is completely a Pirate of the Caribbean.
Wu Song, as one of the infantry twins among the heroes of Liangshan, his personal strength cannot be questioned.
But the new version of Wu Song has really been weakened too much, and there is no boldness and majesty of Shandong Dahan.
Chen Long is a good actor, but in the role of Wu Song, there is still no one who can surpass Ding Haifeng.
There is a big difference between the old and new versions in terms of character creation.
First of all, the big boss Song Jiang is two completely different directions, the old version of Song Jiang is obscene, greedy for life and afraid of death, submissive, and flattering.
Back then, the audience watched him lead his brothers to accept Zhao'an, and in the end, they were killed and injured, and they were so angry that they smashed the TV.
So much so that now many netizens call him "Tianpouting Star", which annoys people.
And Song Jiang, played by Zhang Hanyu, is much tougher, Zhang Hanyu, as a well-known tough guy, naturally makes Song Jiang look much more powerful.
In the original work, Song Jiang is described like this:The eyes are like a phoenix, and the eyebrows are like lying silkworms. Dripping two earlobe beads, bright eyes dotted with paint. The lips are square, and the mustache is light; The forehead is wide and the top is flat, and the skin and flesh are full. When he sits like a tiger, he walks like a wolf.
And it's clearly usedAmbitious and beautiful-mindedSuch an adjective.
From this point of view, Zhang Hanyu's version is closer to the original work, while Mr. Li Xuejian has added a lot of his own understanding.
The focus of the old version is that Song Jiang was Zhao'an and regarded the brothers as bargaining chips, while the new version enhances Song Jiang's heroism and leadership.
In addition to the different characters in terms of personality, there are also too many differences in shape.
I don't understand why the new version of the characters is always dressed in a draped style, although everyone is a good man in the green forest, different, but these weird hairstyles really affect the perception.
If it is said that King Kong Song Wan in the clouds, General Shi Shi Yong and others are all leftovers on Liangshan, and the shape is more weird and alternative.
Dai Zonggui, the Shenxing Taibao, is Tiangangxing, a core member of the group, and he has also changed this non-mainstream hairstyle.
I don't know that I thought he was a Khitan or a Xixia person, but in terms of modeling, the new version of "Water Margin" suffered a big loss.
The old version looks much more comfortable, which is in line with everyone's imagination of Liangshan heroes.
The new version of "Water Margin" mostly restores the original work in terms of plot arrangement, and Song Jiang is also "rehabilitated".
But in terms of character modeling, there is a strong Hong Kong style, just like the former "Fengyun", all of which are cloaked.
The old version is better in character building, each character is full and flesh and blood.
For the old and new versions of "Water Margin", which version do you prefer?
Especially the shaping of the two versions of Pan Jinlian, which one is more exciting?
**10,000 Fans Incentive Plan