Movies and TV series are not perfect, so "Scout Heroes" has received some criticism, which is also a common thing.
However, there are also some people who have made negative comments about "Scout Heroes", and some people's evaluations are obviously unfair, not because there is anything wrong with the film itself, but because of their own opinions and opinions.
1. Ignorance of history.
The movie "Scout Heroes" combines many typical battles of the War to Resist US Aggression and Aid Korea, which can be recognized at a glance by those who are more familiar with history, and has a strong sense of intimacy, but for those who do not understand this, it is an unbelievable thing.
Here are a few typical examples:
The Volunteer Army blocked the mountains and closed the road, this is the actual combat experience of the 42nd Army, when the War to Resist US Aggression and Aid Korea Huangcaoling, it was such an example, and there were also such examples in "Reconnaissance Heroes".
The Americans are walking up the hill with heavy machine guns on the surrounding hills**, this is not a waste of ammunition, this is also the way the Americans fight, when they are on the front line, they often turn on machine guns and lights to reassure themselves.
Liang Chen led the troops to quickly rescue the song and dance troupe, which was a real combat case of the 42nd Army and a successful case of our army's defeat of the US communications troops.
The surprise attack on Yujiang Bridge by the Volunteer Army was an actual battle of the 38th Army, and the film "Surprise Attack" was also based on it.
Liang Chen encountered a regular army of the Korean People's Army on a Yu River in the rear of the enemy, and the deputy commander of the 42nd Division of the 125th Army, Jo Fu Yi, recalled that he met his old friend Lu Zhe and led a Korean People's Army of more than 20,000 men to retreat to the north.
Wen Jie was blown up by the Americans and buried in a bunker, and the division commander ordered her and her comrades to be rescued, which is the story that Wang Fuzhi, deputy commander of the 115th Division of the 39th Army Corps, has personally experienced.
The predecessor of the South Korean "Fox Squad" was based on the US-led South Korean Leopard and Donkey guerrillas.
Liang Chen led the troops to raid the headquarters of a Leopard Division, which was based on the assault led by Yang Yucai, deputy squad leader of the reconnaissance squad of the 607th Regiment of the 203rd Division of the 68th Army Corps, to raid the White Tiger Regiment, this famous battle was adapted into Peking Opera, movies, TV series, among which soldiers stepped on anti-tank mines during the raid.
These are real-life cases in "Recon Heroes", and there are many classics and legends, and people who don't know history are likely to take these legendary battles as mythical stories, so there will be negative reviews.
2. Rigid thinking.
Most of the negative reviews of the movie "Scout Heroes" are aimed at the heroine Wen Jie.
If someone says that Ma Sichun acted badly or Wen Jie didn't act well, they all have their own opinions, even if they don't agree, there is no reason to refute it.
But there are also some people who give negative reviews:
The big war is coming, how can there be time to fall in love?
Why do military movies and TV series need emotional scenes?
I can't stand the scene of volunteers talking about love.
The whole school is talking about Liang Chen, Wen Jie, especially the teacher, which is too much.
And for the emotional part of "Scout Hero", it is completely denied, which is a kind of rigid thinking.
First of all, Liang Chen's age, position and resume all meet the requirements of the army's "258th Regiment", if he wants to find a good man, he can even fall in love with him, and even marry a wife.
In fact, in the Korean war, it is not uncommon for volunteers to promise each other and to each other, and the closest relationship with Liang Chen Wenjie is Wang Qianxiang, the political commissar of the 350th Regiment of the 117th Division of the 39th Army Corps, and Shen Zhenglin, a young cadre, the two met at the beginning of the dynasty, and got married half a year later.
Secondly, the War to Resist US Aggression and Aid Korea did not last long, and after five battles, both countries were in a stalemate, with only a few large battles, and the rest of the time they were fairly balanced.
There are more than 1 million soldiers and logistics soldiers who have volunteered to participate in the battle, and as long as they do not delay their work and abide by discipline, they can naturally fall in love and get married.
Besides, it is not uncommon for the leaders of the military region to help Liang Chen and Wen Jie introduce their partners, even General Chen Geng was matched by General Liu Deng, and Liang Chen, as the head of the reconnaissance section of the military region, is also a deputy position, so it is also very common for the division commander to arrange blind dates.
Moreover, Liang Chen is the "** bachelor" of the entire company, not only has a high position and strength, but also is very handsome. Wen Jie is a very talented person and a beautiful person. When these two people are together, they will naturally attract the attention of the entire academy.
The volunteer army is generally tens of thousands of people, similar to a university college, Liang Chen is the most handsome school grass, and Wen Jie is the most beautiful girl, the two of them are together, it will definitely attract a lot of people's attention, and such things are not common on the front line, so it is more valuable.
The problem is that some people think of volunteers as too simple, dull, and dull, and take for granted that they are all ascetics, with no life, no joy, and no romance, which is a big mistake.
There is a love story about volunteers in Scout Heroes, which is a good choice, and it is also to let more people know the real past and let them know these volunteers better.
3. Improper buttocks.
Neither of these people's evaluations is very accurate, but at least they are all facts, and there are still some "viewers" on the Internet who give "Scout Heroes" all kinds of negative reviews, and it seems that they are not very satisfied with the film, but a very strange feeling.
Some people used the South Korean film "Taiji Flag Flying" to fight back, believing that it was the KPA that killed the North Korean people, while "Reconnaissance Hero" deliberately slandered the South Korean army.
In fact, the incident of the South Korean army killing civilians is not only reported by the United States and South Korea, but even South Korea has recognized it, and even set up a special group, neither the United States nor South Korea has refuted it, but Chinese netizens have even stood up to speak for them, this is too much, right?
There are also people who deny the achievements of volunteer reconnaissance, and feel that the investigators in "Reconnaissance Heroes" are simply immortals. In fact, Zhang Kuiyin led the army to raid the Wuling Bridge, and Yang Yucai led the army to raid the White Tiger Regiment, both of which are legends far beyond "Scout Heroes", not to mention countless Korean soldiers such as Liu Guangzi and Chai Yunzhen.
It can only be said that our directors are sometimes too humble and will not shoot those real war cases at all.
Of course, there are also people who completely deny the glorious victory in the War to Resist US Aggression and Aid Korea, whether they have seen it or not.
They don't care about the real ending of the War to Resist US Aggression and Aid Korea at all, they don't care about what war the two sides are fighting, and they don't care about the actual effect and historical value of the founding battle.
"Reconnaissance Heroes" is one of them, but it restores the details of the battlefield, reproduces the classic battle scenes, and restores the real history, this is a movie to resist US aggression and aid Korea, and it is a very commendable movie.