The grandfather thought the child was too noisy and hurt him, so why was he acquitted

Mondo Social Updated on 2024-03-08

In February 2012, a woman in Kaixian County, Chongqing, received a call from her husband when she was at work"Come back quickly! Something happened to Vivi. ”After hearing this, the woman hurriedly asked for leave and rode home, but she panicked for a moment and ignored her husband's tone, if she listened carefully, she could find that her husband did not have the slightest sense of urgency.

Text |Pioneer of Law

Edit |Pioneer of Law

When she got home, she saw her 8-month-old daughter, Vivi, but not in her cradle, but in the ambulanceHer daughter's forehead was bruised, blood was oozing from the back of her head, and the little man had long since lost her breath.

At the same time, her father-in-law was also in the ambulance, but he didn't say a word, and after the doctor's explanation, she knew that her ownThe daughter fell from the third floor of the house, and her father-in-law jumped off her heels.

No mother can calm down after her child has suffered such an injury, she stepped forward and grabbed her father-in-law and asked: "How do you look at the child, how can she fall off at such a young age!" ”

Was Vivi's fall an accident or man-made? If it is man-made, who can be so ruthless? There are only Weiwei's relatives in the house, no matter who it is, it is unacceptable.

That night, only 8-month-old Wei Wei was given a death notice, her mother Liu Yan cried and almost fainted, and the next day Liu Yan's mother also came, she helped Liu Yan organize the child's funeral together, but Liu Yan's father-in-law could not come, because he was taken to the hospital and was taken away by the police after being checked out without incident.

But neither the child's father nor grandmother showed up, Liu Yan's mother was furious, and immediately went to Liu Yan's husband's house and questioned the child's grandmother: "I don't take good care of the child, your family is all sinners!" What do you mean by burying the child now, and you don't show up? Which of you killed the child? Guilty? ”

Liu Yan's mother scolded very ugly, and pushed and shoved with her hands, but the child's grandmother just didn't say a word, and when she saw that she couldn't resist, she quickly ran back to the room and closed the door, the child's father was also at home, and when he heard his mother-in-law coming, he had already hidden, and Liu Yan asked him after pulling him out:"Tell me, what do you mean by the police taking away your dad! Did your dad throw Vivi down? ”

Xiao Jun was very angry when he heard this: "How can you think like this? My dad is her own grandfather, how could he do this, it was Weiwei who rolled down by herself, what does it matter to my dad? ”

But Xiao Jun's words Liu Yan will not believe it, although their family has built three floors, but because they have no money to decorate the upper two floors, they have always lived on the first floor, and they will only go up to the third floor when they are drying clothes, Weiwei can't go up by herself, she must have been brought by her father-in-law Xiao Youfu.

And she is just an 8-month-old baby, there is a railing upstairs, it is impossible for the child to climb up and fall down by himself, she scolded Xiao Jun, saying that he was full of nonsense, he must be covering up his father!

This matter has caused a huge discussion in the village, and many people are saying that Xiao Youfu is really vicious, and the tiger poison is not a child, and he is really unbearable as a grandfather, but there is also a voice that came into Liu Yan's earsSome people speculate that it was not Xiao Youfu who did it at all, but Xiao Jun, Weiwei's biological father!

When she first heard this kind of remarks, Liu Yan was also shocked, cold sweat broke out behind her back, and she was extremely frightened, but it was only a bold guess by the people in the village, and she couldn't take it seriously, but the appearance of the next person made Liu Yan have to believe that this guess was somewhat true.

One morning, Liu Yan saw a familiar figure at the door of her house and took a closer lookis Xiao Jun's ex-wife, Sister Tian, She didn't have anything to do with this person, and she hadn't even met a few times, she asked Sister Tian what she was doing here, and Sister Tian's words made Liu Yan ponder. ”

I'm here to see my daughter this time, and yesterday I heard that your daughter Vivi had suffered a misfortune, and I was very tormented in my heart, and I was also worried that something would happen to my daughter, so I came to take a look. ”

Sister Tian and Xiao Jun did not take their daughter away after their divorce, this girl is now out of school and is often not at home, so where does Sister Tian's worry come from? Liu Yan asked.

I divorced Xiao Jun before because they hadSerious patriarchal thinkingSince I gave birth to my daughter, Xiao Jun's family's attitude towards me has changed greatlyXiao Jun even punched and kicked me from time to time, and my mother-in-law always disliked me for giving birth to a daughterand sometimes don't even want me to eat at the table. ”

This time Weiwei had an accident, I was afraid that they would do such a thing to my daughter, so I secretly came to take a look. ”

After listening to Sister Tian's words, Liu Yan was furious in her heart, she was really blind at the beginning, not only jumped into the fire pit herself, but also caused her daughter to pay the price of her life for her wrong choice.

If this is the case, the child's father, Xiao Jun, is also suspicious! She immediately reported her suspicion to the police station, and the police also told her that the place where her daughter fell was more than ten meters away from her building, and it is impossible for an elderly person in her 60s to throw it so far.

This evidence further confirmed Liu Yan's conjecture, she endured the pain in her heart and waited for the police to take her husband away, at this moment, her heart was full of resentment towards the family!

Later, the police also summoned Xiao Jun to the past, and in the face of the police's questioning, Xiao Jun said very seriously and with a little anger:"That's wronging me! Since there was no evidence, Xiao Jun was released home.

But the news that he was summoned away by the police reached the ears of the villagers, and everyone talked about it, saying that it was the cruel hand of the child's father, hearing these rumors, Xiao Jun burned a lot of paper for Weiwei at the place where Weiwei had an accident downstairs in his house, and knelt down to ask for his daughter's forgiveness, so that people could see that he was also very sorry for his daughter's death.

But all this is pretending to be in Liu Yan's eyes, acting for those who gossip about him, but in fact, he doesn't care about the life and death of a girl in his heart, even if it is his biological daughter, he is a complete cold-blooded animal.

A week later, the investigation was almost completeThe police determined that the murderer was Xiao Youfu, that is, the child's grandfather, Liu Yan was very dissatisfied when she heard this result, she felt that the three people in the family should be responsible for her daughter's death, but at this moment, the police station suddenly came out,Xiao Youfu was acquitted!

Liu Yan's heart hurt as if she had been pierced by a needle, why! Why should the murderer be acquitted!

It turned out that just when Xiao Youfu was about to be sentenced, Xiao Jun stood upSaid his father had intermittent psychosis, I hope to be lenient with his father, after the doctor's diagnosis, it is really just like Xiao Jun said, so Xiao Youfu becauseIncapacity for criminal responsibility, acquitted.

The police asked Xiao Youfu why he ruthlessly killed his own granddaughter, and he said:"The child kept crying, and it was so annoying, so I hit her twice with a brick, and she was still crying, so I threw it down, and then I fell down myself. ”

But since Xiao Youfu was acquitted, Liu Yan no longer believed anything the family said, they told all the lies in order to cover up their family, and the poor daughter was tortured to death by this family.

Later, the marriage was also divorced, and Liu Yan also left a huge mental trauma, not only her children are pitiful, but she herself is not a pitiful person?

In the above-mentioned cases, everyone must also be very puzzled, why can they say that they are mentally ill and do not have to bear criminal responsibility?

First of all, it is necessary to understand which persons fall within the scope of criminal incapacity, which means that the perpetrator does not possess or loses the ability to recognize or control his or her own behavior.

Among them, where a mentally ill person causes harmful results when he is unable to recognize or control his own behavior, and it is confirmed through legal procedures, he does not bear criminal responsibility; Intermittent mentally ill persons who commit crimes when they are mentally normal shall bear criminal responsibility.

In this case, Xiao Youfu was found to have committed the crime when his illness was attacking, so he was not found criminally responsible, but he had done something that endangered the lives of othersThe police ordered his family to be strictly guarded and treated, and if necessary, to be subjected to compulsory medical treatment by **.

But if Xiao Youfu did not get ill at that time, and he just used his illness as a shield to exonerate himself, then, according to the provisions of the criminal law, he should be sentencedIntentional homicide.

According to article 232 of the Criminal Law, whoever intentionally kills a person shall be sentenced to death, life imprisonment or fixed-term imprisonment of not less than 10 years; where the circumstances are more minor, the sentence is between three and ten years imprisonment.

But in any case, Xiao Youfu should not kill his own granddaughter because of the patriarchal thinking in his heart, and his "** Xiao Jun and his mother should not let Xiao Youfu and Weiwei be alone when they know that Xiao Youfu has intermittent mental illness.

Cases of infanticide were very common in ancient times, in the famine years, people changed their children and eaten, and in peacetime people mutilated female babies because of patriarchy, until modern times, after being able to find out the sex of the child in the womb, there are still many people who kill the female baby, only after the state has legislated on this, the idea that the birth of boys and girls are the same has begun to popularize.

But life is precious for both men and womenNot to mention that this is only an 8-month-old baby, any legal provision on the protection of minors is very necessary, and it is also a wake-up call for adults.

There was once a case that challenged the bottom line of this society, and that isIn 2006, Shaanxi's first case of child abuse and murder occurred.

On March 29, 06, a cleaner was cleaning up the garbage dump when a body suddenly fell from a high pile of garbage, and he ran out in fright, and the police cordoned off the garbage dump after calling the police.

It was forensically identified as a 9-year-old boyAfter that, the police station dispatched more than 80 police officers to form a special case team, which lasted nearly 6 months before the murderer was arrested.

* is a man, named Zhang Bin, this nine-year-old boy was tricked by him into a rental house and then carried out **, and then killed people, once his crime was committed, he became what people called "** murderer".

But according to him, he was also a victim, but no one stood up for him at that time to seek justice, it turned out that Zhang Bin was seduced by a man with candy when he was 9 years old, and violated him, after the age of 10, he became a homeless man on the street, it is not easy to grow up, not to mention whether he can establish a healthy psychology.

Later, during the search of Zhang Bin's rental house, ** found that he had a notebook dedicated to recording the victim, on which a total of 9 children were recordedThe oldest is only 15 years old, and the youngest is only 8 years old, they were deceived by some candy and a few loose change.

In the end, Zhang Bin was punished by the law and was sentenced to a heavy sentence on suspicion of **, homicide and other crimes.

This case and the case of Xiao Youfu's granddaughter who fell to death are both reminding people that as the guardian of the child, we must take responsibility and strengthen the children's sense of self-prevention.

Related Pages