In 1955, the controversy over Su Yu's award to the rank of marshal has been a hot topic. Does he exactly qualify to be a marshal?Has he ever resigned from the rank of marshal?This article will delve into this controversial historical issue.
Marshal rank standards revealed.
The criteria for awarding the rank of marshal seem to be clear, and the requirements are for the creation and leadership of the people's armed forces or the leadership of the campaign corps in battle, and the senior general who has made outstanding meritorious contributions. However, only one of these two conditions is sufficient. At first glance, Su Yu does not seem to meet the first condition, because in the Nanchang Uprising, he was only a guard squad leader, dwarfed by other uprising leaders. During the period of the Red Army, his position was also limited to the chief of staff of the Red Tenth Army Corps, and he did not have the authority to independently command the troops. Therefore, according to this criterion, it seems unlikely that Su Yu will be awarded the rank of marshal.
Outstanding military exploits: Su Yu's brilliant performance.
However, the key lies in the second condition, "leading the campaign corps in battle and making outstanding contributions." Su Yu performed well in the Liberation War and was perfect. He showed outstanding military talent in early battles such as the Soviet-Chinese Seven Battles, the Subei Campaign, the Lunan Campaign, and the Laiwu Campaign. What is even more remarkable is that his command performance in the East China Battlefield has been highly recognized. ** was once sent to Shandong to command, but due to the successive defeats in the Lian War, ** had to transfer Su Yu to East China, so that the East China Field Army created an unprecedented victory in the Lian Battle and Victory. This series of victories made ** excitedly say: "Our East China Field Army has just created an unprecedented victory in the three recent battles of Subei, Lunan and Luzhong, and it was broken by the next bigger victory. ”
Behind the assessment of the rank of marshal.
Regarding whether Su Yu is qualified to become a marshal, some people once excluded him from the ranks of marshals because he did not serve as a member of the ** Military Commission. However, this argument is untenable. As early as the early days of the founding of the People's Republic of China in 1949, Su Yu was already a member of the ** Military Commission, alongside the other nine marshals, and there were 11 members of the ** Military Commission at that time, including the top ten marshals and *** Therefore, the reason why Su Yu did not become a marshal was not because he was not a member of the ** Military Commission, but because of other reasons.
Su Yu resigned the truth about the marshal's rank.
Regarding whether Su Yu resigned from the rank of marshal, there is a powerful testimony from Li Yinqiao, the chief of the guard. When reviewing the list of marshals, ** had stated that Su Yu was enough to become a marshal in terms of merit, history, talent, and morality. However, ** mentioned that Su Yu had asked to resign. ** I regretted this, thinking that Su Yu was "rare", and resigned as marshal three times, which was more precious than others. This statement was also corroborated in the mouth of Su Yu's old subordinate Guan Meiying, ** revealed to Guan Meiying that Su Yu's resignation of the marshal was well known in the high-level, but it was not conveyed to the below.
The three major unfinished tasks.
In the end, although Su Yu did not become a marshal, if he could complete the three major tasks, namely serving as the commander and political commissar of Huaye, liberating Taiwan, and commanding the Chinese Volunteers to participate in the War to Resist US Aggression and Aid Korea, then even if he resigned, ** would not agree not to grant him the rank of marshal. However, due to various reasons, these three tasks could not be achieved, making it difficult for Su Yu to let go of his life.
Epilogue. 
The mystery of Marshal Su Yu is still a subject of much controversy and concern. Through the standard of the marshal's rank, outstanding military exploits, the qualifications of the members of the Military Commission, the truth about the resignation of the marshal's rank, and the three unfinished tasks, we have a more comprehensive understanding of this period of history. Although Su Yu did not eventually become a marshal, his outstanding performance in the War of Liberation will always be remembered.
Analysis of Marshal Su Yu: Historical Exploration and Leader Selection.
The mystery of Marshal Su Yu's title has always been a historical topic that has attracted attention. In the article, the marshal standard, outstanding military exploits, the qualifications of the members of the Military Commission, the truth about the resignation of the marshal's rank, and the unfinished three major tasks are detailed and presented, presenting a rich and complex historical picture.
First of all, the analysis of the standard of the rank of marshal reveals that the rank of marshal is not only to lead the people's armed forces, but also focuses on leading the campaign corps to fight and achieve outstanding feats. The flexibility of this standard created room for Su Yu's controversy, giving him a clear advantage in "leading the campaign corps in battle and making outstanding contributions."
Secondly, the in-depth analysis of Su Yu's outstanding performance in the Liberation War presents readers with a true portrait of a military genius. The quotations and examples in the article clearly highlight Su Yu's strategic wisdom and outstanding command skills in the East China Theater. His record is not only impressive, but also perfect, making the marshal's standard of "leading the battle corps in battle and making outstanding meritorious deeds" shine brightly.
Regarding the controversy over the qualifications of the members of the Military Commission, the article effectively clarified the fundamental reason why Su Yu failed to become a marshal. He became a member of the ** Military Commission as early as the early days of the founding of the People's Republic of China, and the subsequent changes were not because of qualifications, but for deeper reasons, which opened a door to history for readers.
The revelation of the rank of marshal presents a more real and three-dimensional image of Su Yu through the testimony of Li Yinqiao, the chief of the guard, and Guan Meiying, Su Yu's old subordinate. **Regret for Su Yu's three resignations, as well as ***'s explanation of resignations, add a touch of mysterious brilliance to Su Yu's historical image.
Finally, the discussion of the three unfinished tasks makes the reader more sympathetic to Marshal Su Yu's life. The setbacks of the three unfinished tasks left a trace of regret in Su Yu's life, which may be one of the reasons why he left a deep imprint on the long river of history.
In general, the history of Marshal Su Yu is not only the deeds of a military general, but also a part of the history of the Chinese revolution. Through the analysis of the marshal's criteria, military exploits, qualifications, resignations, and unfinished tasks, the article gives readers a deeper understanding of the life of this outstanding military leader, and also enlightens us to take a more comprehensive view of his achievements and limitations when evaluating historical figures.
Disclaimer: The above content information is ** on the Internet, and the author of this article does not intend to target or insinuate any real country, political system, organization, race, or individual. The above content does not mean that the author of this article agrees with the laws, rules, opinions, behaviors in the article and is responsible for the authenticity of the relevant information. The author of this article is not responsible for any issues arising from the above or related issues, and does not assume any direct or indirect legal liability.
If the content of the article involves the content of the work, copyright**, infringement, rumors or other issues, please contact us to delete it. Finally, if you have any different thoughts about this event, please leave a message in the comment area to discuss!