Once upon a time, there was a young college student named Wang Li. He came from a poor family, he was the only one studying outside the home, and he had a bedridden father to take care of him. In order to pay for living expenses and tuition, Wang Li often works part-time. Full of exhaustion, he lives a busy and hard life every day.
One weekend, after Wang Li was busy with his last job, he carefully looked at the time, and immediately picked up his schoolbag and hurried to the bus station. At this time, he saw that the 919 bus he was about to take was right in front of him. Wang Li quickly quickened his pace, and finally squeezed into the carriage before the bus left the station, and he finally breathed a sigh of relief.
There weren't too many people in the car, so Wang Li chose his favorite window seat and sat down. Soon after he sat down, he suddenly had a bad premonition, and couldn't help but turn around to confirm whether he was sitting in the old man's seat. Confirming that he was seated in an ordinary seat, Wang Li breathed a sigh of relief and leaned against the window with relief, drowsy.
Wang Li is a sophomore in college, and due to his poor family, he has to work part-time to make ends meet. Whether it is attending classes or working part-time, he is very hard. On this day, he was so tired that he didn't even have the mood to enjoy the scenery along the way, and when he got into the car, he fell asleep comfortably. He didn't know how long he had been asleep when five old men walked up in the car. They all smelled of alcohol, but at a glance they saw that there were still four empty seats in the car. Uncle Guo, the last old man to walk into the carriage, had no vacant seats to sit.
Uncle Guo walked up to Wang Li after looking around, patted Wang Li hard, and woke him up. Wang Li opened his sleepy eyes, but looked at Uncle Guo in front of him unknowingly. And Uncle Guo picked up Wang Li's clothes with one hand and asked him to give up his seat. Wang Li was already very tired, and he firmly believed that he was not sitting in the old man's seat, so he politely said to Uncle Guo: "Uncle, I'm really tired, please find someone else to ask." However, Uncle Guo was so angry when he heard Wang Li's words, he thought that the young man should give up his seat, so he raised his palm and slapped Wang Li heavily in the face.
Wang Li covered his face with his hands and clenched his fists, he remembered that his father had told him: "We who are small families can't compete with others about right and wrong, more things are better than less, and patience will pass." Wang Li, who calmed down, stopped talking and closed his eyes to try to avoid the conflict.
However, Uncle Guo was even more angry when he saw Wang Li's attitude, and he slapped Wang Li three times in a row. Wang Li couldn't bear it anymore and stood up and had an argument with Uncle Guo. In the end, Wang Li stood up and left his seat, and Uncle Guo immediately jumped up and sat on the seat. While cocking Erlang's legs to enjoy himself, he scolded Wang Li for not knowing how to respect the old and love the young.
After Wang Li got off the bus, the passengers on the bus accused Uncle Guo of his behavior, but Uncle Guo did not feel the slightest sense of guilt, but he was complacent about winning the seat. However, after leaving a few stops, suddenly, Uncle Guo felt uncomfortable, and he suddenly collapsed in his seat. The people around him didn't dare to step forward to help him, for fear of being falsely accused. The driver quickly stopped and called paramedics to come to the rescue. Even after emergency rescue, Uncle Guo still couldn't save his life, and he passed away like this.
When Uncle Guo's son learned of his father's death, he decided to claim compensation from the bus company and investigated the situation at that time. The bus company provided the monitoring on the bus at that time**, which proved that it was not the driver's driving error that caused Uncle Guo's death.
However, Uncle Guo's son saw in ** that his father and Wang Li had a quarrel, so he thought that Wang Li caused his father's death. So, he sued Wang Li in court and demanded 500,000 yuan in compensation for mental damages.
Uncle Fan's point of view: Wang Li should not refuse to give up his seat, respecting the old and loving the young is the traditional virtue of the Chinese nation. Although Wang Li is already very tired, in the face of an old man asking for help, he should consider the other party's feelings more. Especially in public, giving up a seat is a sign of politeness and respect, and even if he may not be sitting in a loving seat, he can still help those in need.
Grandma Liu's point of view: Wang Li is not wrong, he did not sit on the seat of love, and he himself is very tired and has the right to choose to rest. While respecting the elderly and loving the young is a virtue, it does not mean that all the elderly should give up their seats. Everyone has their own situation and rights, and Wang Li should not be forced to make sacrifices. Uncle Guo's excited beating and insulting young people is also not in line with the principles of respect and politeness, and he should be held responsible for his gaffes.
Legal Opinions:1According to China's Tort Liability Law, when an accident occurs, liability should be determined according to the degree of fault. In this incident, the bus company has proven that the driver did not make a driving error, so the company's fault can be ruled out.
2.Wang Li, who had a quarrel on the way and led to an argument, although it disrupted public order to a certain extent, did not directly lead to the death of Uncle Guo. Therefore, it cannot be determined that he was the direct cause of Uncle Guo's death.
3.In view of the above two points, I believe that Uncle Guo's son's claim against Wang Li lacks legal basis.
4.In the event of a similar incident in the future, passengers shall respect and understand each other and maintain good public order. Bus companies should also strengthen the order management and safety of passengers to ensure the safety of passengers.
In this way, the story leaves a suspense about whether the dispute between Wang Li and Uncle Guo will have an ending in court. The audience will be looking forward to the next episode.